SIHH 2017: Jaeger Lecoultre Reverso Classic Large / Medium case, Automatic movement.

Feb 02, 2017,23:44 PM
 

Behind the discrete revolution, a Reverso Classic with an automatic movement, a big question. 

There are two schools: 

The old school, purists?, who think that the Reverso has to house a manual winding movement, unless it is a sporty model. 

The others, who think that an automatic movement is not so incongruous in a Reverso, even Classic. 

I for one am in the first camp. 

You? 

The Reverso Classic Large: 


The Reverso Classic Medium: 


Looking forward to reading your comments and thoughts on that matter. 

Best,

Nicolas


More posts: Jaeger LeCoultre

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Hmm

 
 By: robsallnow : February 3rd, 2017-00:33
My choice is for manual because it allows a double dial in a nice thin case. I'm sure many a purist would insist a Reverso has a solid caseback and not another dial or display back

manual, of course!

 
 By: Sebi : February 3rd, 2017-00:56
Not only just because, but also for the thinner case it allows, which is the "natural" look & feel of the reverso. After trying (last summer) a medium one on my lady's wrist, we both much much prefer the previous offering, which we eventually managed ... 

Hmmhh.. +1 on manual, thinner & chance f 2 dials in Duo, Tribute Duo etc.. :))

 
 By: hs111 : February 3rd, 2017-01:17
.. although I\'m not militant about it & BTW: Sometimes manuals could contain a full Dial incl GMT & jour/nuit & Gde Date, even with an 8-days Mvmt.. But, as said +1 for man Camp ! Best, hs

In my opinion, a Reverso being a form watch should have a form movement...

 
 By: Sandgroper : February 3rd, 2017-01:29
......having a rectangular "rotor" seems very inconvenient due to its uselessness, therefore I am a strong supporter for a manual movement in a Reverso. KR Francois

I have had long exchanges with Alex from the Vacheron Constantin forum...

 
 By: Sandgroper : February 3rd, 2017-04:49
....in my strongly opinionated view, there was NO excuse for a High Horological Maison, not to install into, or to develop a Form Movement for a Form Case Watch. Eventually, I think the message came through, the proof is on the pudding! Kind regards Franc... 

Agreed. [nt]

 
 By: amanico : February 3rd, 2017-05:04

Manual... why fix it if it ain't broke...

 
 By: Julian C : February 3rd, 2017-02:03
... as the old saying goes. It is a classic, let it remain so. Totally agree with you!

Manual, of course

 
 By: rnaden : February 3rd, 2017-02:31
That\'s my view because I like the idea of leaving a classic alone...my wife thinks it shouldn\'t matter as those in her mind would not want to remember to wind a watch each morning, especially so when there is no seconds hand to tell you that it is runni... 

As a "Purist"...

 
 By: watchme : February 3rd, 2017-06:21
I prefer the manual for several reasons: (1) it's the original design (at a time when no one had a rotor-winding auto); (2) it allows for thinner complications - both single and double-sided; (3) manual-winds have the fewest problems of all watches I know... 

Well DUH...

 
 By: Esharp : February 3rd, 2017-08:13
Hahaha! Of course it has to be manual! And with a rectangular movement. Thanks to JLC for bringing out the Classic this year again with the 822 (I think, would have to check). What I\'d really like is a Classic with 822, sapphire back (yes, not much help ... 

The Cal 822 is a very nice and good movement. I am working on an article about decoration...

 
 By: amanico : February 3rd, 2017-08:17
And mentioned this movement. If I find the time to end it, I will post. Soon, I hope. Best, Nicolas

Please!

 
 By: Esharp : February 3rd, 2017-20:18
And some detailed photos of the reissued manual Reverso would be great too. Have they upgraded the bracelet that is on offer, to include the quick-change system and micro-adjustment in the new Geophysic line? Here\'s what I want: -A classic hand-wound Rev... 

I have a photo of a manual Reverso. The Classic Medium Les Ateliers Reverso. You will love it.

 
 By: amanico : February 3rd, 2017-22:08
As for your wishes, I am pretty sure this day will come. As for the bracelet, ala Reverso Gran Sport? Best, Nicolas

Fantastic!

 
 By: Esharp : February 3rd, 2017-22:20
Please share that photo And yes, the bracelet as you describe...although as I remember it that one was quite \'robust\' in appearance to go with the sportier nature of the watch; it could use some toning-down. Best E.

Too true

 
 By: Esharp : February 3rd, 2017-22:33
So many pitfalls - the links themselves; the clasp; and most of all, the attachment to the watch... I don\'t need bracelets. I\'d be just as happy with a selection of easily-changed and easily-adjusted leather and rubber straps! But for the manufacturers ... 

JLC is using an adjustable strap on some watches such as the Extreme Lab 2.

 
 By: amanico : February 3rd, 2017-22:59
Like you, I would be very pleased to see that system generalized.... Best, my friend. Nicolas

Yes, exactly...

 
 By: Esharp : February 4th, 2017-00:12
Adjustable and easily changed! Best E.

Manual FTW!!!

 
 By: JFT : February 3rd, 2017-08:56
But sadly, due to the crisis in watchmaking world.... I think JLC is targeting even more people who doesn't even familiar with horology, and most of them think that mechanical watches are those that "works" whenever they put it on... And most of the times... 

We're watch nuts...come on Nico

 
 By: mahesh : February 3rd, 2017-12:39
it\'s manual hands down & another benefit - a cleaner dial too ;-) Best, mahesh.,

manual for me too, but

 
 By: Robert_ : February 8th, 2017-04:28
I seriously doubt that novice buyers would even care about the movement at all. They will be attracted to the brand/story/model, rather than the heritage and proper movement. Only when one gets more involved you start to care about details that matter bey...