patrick_y
[PuristSPro Moderator]
33643
Oooh! Lovely collection.
You're right! I forgot you already experienced Japanese pens. Sorry, I don't remember everything, I must be getting old! Sailor is definitely a little different. There's a slight scratchy texture to Sailors which I sometimes like and I sometimes don't like. The Sailor is definitely different!
The Namiki factory is mainly focused on the Maki-E and urushi. From what I gathered in my tour, tour was a one-on-one tour with a Japanese speaking docent and my Japanese is quite bad, so speaking about precise details was difficult. From what I gathered, the fountain pen nib is made in a Pilot factory, but the nib and feed are assembled at the Namiki factory (which makes sense since Namiki uses different feeds than Pilot). The Pilot Urushi and Maki-E pens are also made at the Namiki factory. The Chinkin pens are first urushi pens from the Namiki factory and then they go to the area near the Noto Peninsula (where the earthquake was on 01-Jan-2024) area where the Chinkin artist resides. Namiki doesn't seem to have an actual factory there, but the Chinkin pens are not made in the Namiki factory, from what I gathered.
Another pairing of pens…
Yesterday I posted a photo of two Montblancs that “l love.” That prompted one member to enquire about other pens that I love. The answer is not easy because earlier this year I sold many of my pens, mostly Montblancs, some in boxes and never inked. I simp...
Allow me to make an unsolicited recommendation.
I had been collecting Montblanc pens for over 20 years. And while I always knew about Namiki fountain pens, I never really paid that much attention to them. One day, a few generous individuals loaned me their pens to write with. Some for just 20 minutes. ...
Thank you, Patrick, for the nice reflection about Namiki.
I know Japanese pens well — I have retained two Namikis— they are works of art — plus, one Nakaya. I have tried Sailor pens several times over the years and I have always been disappointed by the writing experience and those pens have not stayed in my col...
Oooh! Lovely collection.
You're right! I forgot you already experienced Japanese pens. Sorry, I don't remember everything, I must be getting old! Sailor is definitely a little different. There's a slight scratchy texture to Sailors which I sometimes like and I sometimes don't lik...
I”m surprised with your feelings with Sailor.
I worship the nibs and writing of that brand. Well, everyone has their preferences.
I do see two camps...
I see people who like the Sailor style of nibs, because they like the "pencil lead feedback" that the Sailor gives. And I see people who value the buttery smoothness of the Namiki. And I see a small amount of people who like both.
I have several Sailors but only
one inexpensive Pilot so I don’t have a solid opinion of this brand. By now.
I've got a friend who adores Sailor.
He still has a few Pilots and a Namiki, but he has more Sailors. He was the one who told me that many people go one direction - to the smoother Namiki/Pilot or to the scratchier Sailor. I frankly find both to be very interesting.
For 20 plus years, my main pen was a Montblanc 146.
I liked other fountain pens, but I kept on going back to the Montblanc 146. Now, my writing style has changed and I'm mainly writing letters and memos to friends. So I'm mainly using a flexible falcon nib fountain pen (from Pilot) that I enjoy very much. ...
My favorite one to write with is the Namiki Emperor.
Something about the size and feel of the nib really appeals to me. I have used all three nib sizes. Didn’t care for the fine, enjoyed the medium, but really adore the broad. I just picked up the new Montblanc 149 from The Origins collection. Haven’t had a...
Namiki Emperor is an amazing pen.
I honestly don't really use my Emperors to write with. A little weird. You must write a lot! I'm mostly writing short memos and thank you cards. So my writings are usually shorter.
I’ve always been more reluctant to spend significant
amounts of money in fountain pens than in watches. Now, you are seriously tempting me. Great reading.
One way to look at it...
Everyone can appreciate a nice car - it's not necessarily indicative of someone with taste. Even rappers and sports stars appreciate nice watches now and is no longer an indication of someone who can appreciate fine mechanics. But fountain pens are one of...
The maki-e Namikis are authentic works of art.
And there’s no periodic maintenance. Any day I go to Madrid, I see one in the flesh and who knows…
There's some maintenance and preventive maintenance.
It's important to clean the pen periodically, more often if you have dirty, perspiring, and/or oily hands. The Urushi lacquer degrades in the sunlight. It's important to avoid strong light exposure, thus, don't put the pen where there is sunlight or under...
Thanks for this valuable info.
I meant that with pens one has not to spend lots of money in the maintenance, all the contrary with watches… With your advice and considering I’m very careful, if I buy a maki-e I think I’ll pay only once.
Oh yes!
You're absolutely right there. Much less goes wrong with a pen! I won't buy Perpetual Calendars anymore. Too much goes wrong and the maintenance on this is just too much!
Perpetual calendars and annual calendars are both problematic.
In general, complex watches don't always work perfectly. The tension on the internals has to be very precise sometimes to encourage the correct changeover. Also, sometimes the leap year doesn't work, and the watch is already out of warranty by the time th...
That one is much more reliable.
In fact, that one is one of the few exceptions to the rule.
Two beautiful pens, thanks for sharing.
I didn’t know that the MB 1912 had a flex nib, it’s sadly quite hard to find quality modern flex nibs, I’ll try to check one if I can manage to find one somewhere.
Oh ok, thanks for the heads up.
I saw that you commented those nibs live in rouge et noir line. I have a rouge et noir bebe, it’s nib is as you described pliable but there is no tine separation, I really like writing with it, one of my favorite pens, I also have a Nakaya with a soft med...
1912...
I have an aversion of recent MBs in general...this said, the 1912 is indeed quite special and somehow, they managed to persuade management to do a nearly one-off nib design: more pliable, more finesse, sweeter, yet not-out-of-control writing experience. T...
I did not know this...
But then, it appears like a Renaissance based on the most recent NYT coverage of a pen show. I would have thought a trickle of visitors but it does appear to be a robust trade to say the least. In the age of data inference and machine learning, every lett...