Good points…

Jun 26, 2021,06:07 AM
 

However I found that trying each in a different size will make you question what color and size is right for you… at least it does for me…

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

OP POLL

 
 By: keks : June 25th, 2021-07:49
Been quite fascinated by the colorful Oyster Perpetuals and looking for opinions…. So, a vote for one of four options below would be my request… 1. 36mm yellow 2. 41mm yellow 3. 36mm red 4. 41mm red Now, since we have a lot of purists here I think 36 will...  

36 mm, red.

 
 By: Bobbe : June 25th, 2021-08:50

36mm yellow - that would be my choice.

 
 By: ronhan : June 25th, 2021-09:27
No message body

NON STANDARD DIALS

 
 By: golden hands : June 25th, 2021-09:28
the coloured dials i assume are not an official option from rolex before you bought one -i would first check with your local AD for rolex and ask them -would they service/repair the watch with the coloured dial as it is non standard, as rolex are very str... 

?

 
 By: PalmSprings : June 25th, 2021-15:03
Where have you been the past year?

Clever

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:04
Or is it?

4 - 41 red

 
 By: sebks : June 25th, 2021-10:01
Initially considered the 36 but it felt too small on my 16.5cm wrist when I tried it. The 41mm does not wear too large at all even if 39mm would have been perfect for a vintage but not too vintage vibe ...  

Looks amazing on you!

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:05
Hmm…

So far i am amazed

 
 By: keks : June 25th, 2021-10:41
At how even the tally is… With seven votes cast two votes each except for red 41 with one vote. That is an even race!!

General leanings to 36mm

 
 By: ArmisT : June 25th, 2021-10:56
I’m seeing a leaning towards 36mm, as you expected. It made me think, and it’s true that the 36mm sizes perhaps have a certain vintage reminiscence, as well as looking elegant in a way that larger watches trade off. But the 41mm don’t wear too big. I have... 

So between these four…

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:15
Your pick would be?

In the end, I’ll still stick with Yellow-41.

 
 By: ArmisT : June 26th, 2021-12:41
Just like sebks said, the 41 doesn’t seem to be too large.

Red 36mm

 
 By: agyzace : June 25th, 2021-10:47

Yellow 41 mm

 
 By: George Gently : June 25th, 2021-10:59

41mm yellow

 
 By: Grisar : June 25th, 2021-11:04

36mm over 41mm

 
 By: Joe90 : June 25th, 2021-11:23
I haven't seen these in the metal but my overall feeling about the non-sport models is that they appear too bulbous over 40mm, where the narrowness of the lugs and the dial size simply don't incorporate very well. So unless you have huge wrists, 36mm gets... 

Good points…

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:07
However I found that trying each in a different size will make you question what color and size is right for you… at least it does for me…

Agreed! I’d rock a candy pink-36 over all the others.

 
 By: ArmisT : June 26th, 2021-12:45
But it seems there aren’t many of these around.

What about the 36mm tiffany blue ?

 
 By: @lberti : June 25th, 2021-12:26
...  

That looks amazing

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:08
But wanted to keep this poll simple… or at least try

My first choice would be 36MM yellow,

 
 By: Thomas_3 : June 25th, 2021-13:16
but as @lberti mentioned the Tiffany blue is quite nice.

36mm yellow dial is my choice.

 
 By: Overwound : June 25th, 2021-13:48
No message body

Having tried them all on.

 
 By: Miles_151 : June 25th, 2021-15:36
In all the colours. I went for the blue 36mm. I though that the 41mm was too big for me and just didn’t look as good as the 36mm on my wrist. I also went for the Tiffany blue and then gave it to my girlfriend for Christmas. So I still get to wear it very ... 

Congrats!

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:09
Well I was convinced one way until I had an opportunity to handle several versions side by side. What struck me was I leaned towards different sizes depending on color of the dial…

Good choice!

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : June 25th, 2021-16:23

Thank you

 
 By: Ivan5 : June 26th, 2021-20:29

Here is an idea: The brighter the dial (or metal), the more a 36mm works versus a 40+mm.

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : June 25th, 2021-16:24
Just my rule. I like the yellow 36mm over the red 36mm.

Yes that makes sense

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:10
Especially on these where the dials are a large part of the visible diameter…

36 white 😉

 
 By: oyster case : June 25th, 2021-16:28

Ok

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:14
But unfortunately not an option for this poll… thanks!

Definitely 36mm

 
 By: dms : June 25th, 2021-16:33
I’ve long hesitated between 36 and 41 myself, and after trying multiple times on my 17,5cm wrist, I came to the conclusion that 36 mm was enough, especially with those very colorful dials. Then I hesitated between red and turquoise. Got the red and after ...  

41mm yellow

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : June 25th, 2021-16:45
...  

36 yellow

 
 By: drhr : June 25th, 2021-17:03

Hard decision, 41 yellow.

 
 By: Musashi83 : June 25th, 2021-19:07

Yellow 41

 
 By: ilie.adrian : June 25th, 2021-21:17
It’s special and more rare colors….

36mm Yellow.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : June 26th, 2021-03:04
To me it’s a little less loud (I know, that might be a strange opinion). Also, with these colours I do think the smaller case is also more subtle.

Makes sense

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:12
I suppose it comes down to the purpose of the watch… 36 is subtle yet 41 playful

Because that would make it less complicated

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:13
And life is not meant to be simple… if they were 38 we would have to find other trivia matters to dwell upon…

Thank you all who voted so far…

 
 By: keks : June 26th, 2021-06:04
Summary so far we got 36y 11 41y 9 36r 4 41r 1 The distribution between red and yellow I had anticipated however the even spilt (almost) between the large and medium sized yellow is surprising to me… I conducted a poll on Instagram as well and will post t... 

IG survey results…

 
 By: keks : June 27th, 2021-04:01
I did post a survey on Instagram and have attached the poll results… not too different from this community votes but with a larger sample size: A clear preference for yellow over red but very even between sizes which surprised me a little. I would have ex...  

Ist 41 Red 2nd 41 Green

 
 By: nacelle : June 28th, 2021-11:30
yellow looks to much like an egg yolk IMO, too dark