Not an easy decision for a pen aficionado

Dec 07, 2020,04:18 AM
 

But I would prefer the Faber Castell. Why? Because of its beauty, the workmanship, and the soul of an family owned business. And of course because FC produces some of the very best nibs in the world. Only topped by the Japanese Big Three (Pilot, Sailor, Namiki).

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

New contest this week...

 
 By: Mike H : December 6th, 2020-16:32
This week’s theme will be pens but the rule doesn’t change : please vote for one of the three and more important tell us the reason(s) of your choice. It might be the composition of the photo that speaks to you, or the lighting, the colours, or the pen it...  

I prefer the Graf von Faber Castell Pen of the Year 2008

 
 By: Rolexwatchx : December 6th, 2020-17:07
The brown finish gets me, it's actually my favorite color. Nice one buddy πŸ€›πŸ»

Thanks for your vote!

 
 By: Mike H : December 6th, 2020-17:24

Anytime my friend

 
 By: Rolexwatchx : December 6th, 2020-17:32

How do faber castells write?

 
 By: Dchang81 : December 6th, 2020-17:20
Never handled one in person, what are they comparable to?

Graf is the premium line of Faber Castell

 
 By: Mike H : December 6th, 2020-17:30
Finishing is perfect and they are made of the best materials and perfectly assembled. The nibs are writing smoothly on the paper. No flex as it is not a vintage nib of course but absolutely perfect for daily use at it writes absolutely perfectly. Dependin... 

GvFC Intuition Platino wood

 
 By: Cardio : December 7th, 2020-22:11
All good, except that there is a tendency for the nib to dry out even while (snap-)capped. The intuition platino wood is possibly the next pen after 'POTY' equal with all the manufacturing merits except for the price, specific year to year design and prec... 

Yes I know the Intuition Platino wood

 
 By: Mike H : December 7th, 2020-23:37
It is the same pen as the Elemento except that the Elemento is made of olive wood instead of grendilla wood. The POTY ones have a screwed cap while the Intuition/Elemento have a snap cap but I have a drying problem of the nib with neither of them. Maybe b... 

These are truly three iconic pens β€”

 
 By: orahu : December 6th, 2020-18:40
But, my immediate or gut reaction was to go with the GvFC β€” the color of the barrel, the contrast with metal cap, the overall composition simply sing out to me. A certain elegance for sure.

Many thanks for your kind words

 
 By: Mike H : December 7th, 2020-11:23
Definitely that GvFC pen is really beautiful without extravaganza, I love this pen (but to be honest I love the two others too πŸ˜‰)

Lovely photographs...

 
 By: cshimokita : December 6th, 2020-22:25
The subject matter lends itself to a series rather than individual images. The lighting seems to match each individual pen. As well the 'setting' complements the uniqueness of each instrument. If forced to choose, it would be the second photo with the bea... 

2d photo with Pelikan & datograph

 
 By: patrickh : December 6th, 2020-23:14
but your pen's collection is also a must have my friend.

Pelikan is my brand so I will stick to this choice here

 
 By: VinnieD : December 6th, 2020-23:52
But that Graf is a very close second! Nice selection of yours

Ah finally one who goes for this beautiful Big Red (not 6263 πŸ˜‰) from 1928

 
 By: Mike H : December 7th, 2020-16:17
I know you by heart I was sure you would go for the vintage one hehehe πŸ‘πŸ‘ŒπŸ‘Œ good choice

You know me well...

 
 By: amanico : December 7th, 2020-23:56

No Namiki?!?

 
 By: Rascal : December 7th, 2020-00:26
I do not vote then !πŸ˜‰

Don't worry there will be still many sessions about pens including many Namiki

 
 By: Mike H : December 7th, 2020-00:38
But for the time being you can look again at these they are not too shabby ...  

One for me my friend ,

 
 By: Watchonthewrists : December 7th, 2020-02:02
The picture is the most pleasant to look at and i like the design of the pen .

Merci mon ami!

 
 By: Mike H : December 8th, 2020-19:03

Not an easy decision for a pen aficionado

 
 By: JLCman : December 7th, 2020-04:18
But I would prefer the Faber Castell. Why? Because of its beauty, the workmanship, and the soul of an family owned business. And of course because FC produces some of the very best nibs in the world. Only topped by the Japanese Big Three (Pilot, Sailor, N... 

Hi Mike

 
 By: Jurry : December 7th, 2020-07:02
Your challenges are becoming increasingly more difficult. Especially this one: product photography; in my view even more difficult than portraits. I find it this time very difficult to chose between photo 1 and 2 and place them both on the first spot. Pho... 

Thanks for your vote and comments my friend

 
 By: Mike H : December 13th, 2020-15:27
Glad you like them and I always welcome constructive comments. FYI this first photo was not intended to land only here on the forum but it was an order from a professional for being published in a BtoB brochure. I fully agree with your comment but it was ... 

Not an easy choice but I vote

 
 By: aWtchslvr : December 7th, 2020-11:34
The Pelikan. I like the sterling silver work that makes a perfect combo with the green. And no doubt the performance it will be flawless.

Aaaah the beautiful Toledo! One of my favourite ones in terms of aesthetics

 
 By: Mike H : December 13th, 2020-16:11
A simple beauty as a daily user, a superb though discrete one

number 3 for me

 
 By: terbaboom : December 12th, 2020-08:17
i like the pen against the cursive writing background number 1 looks like an advertisement

The Big Red has a lot of charm but...

 
 By: Mike H : December 13th, 2020-16:16
...you are so right about the notebook in the background. I actually got it from my grandmother's apartment. It was in the drawer of a cabinet but I have unfortunately no clue about the history of this notebook. Most probably it is related one way or anot... 

How India's artisanal fountain pens are making their mark

 
 By: cshimokita : January 4th, 2021-14:44
An article from the BBC... LINK