I think it's all correctable though. [nt]

Jan 03, 2020,08:39 AM
 

No message body

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

My technique for digital color to b&w conversion YMMV...

 
 By: cshimokita : January 3rd, 2020-00:58
As with all post processing the results are individual interpretations, there is no "correct rendering" for b&w conversions... In the below example I am using Silkypix, and while the application details / tools will be different, most post processing appl...  

Just for fun... next time try 1-2-5

 
 By: cshimokita : January 3rd, 2020-01:38
in moderation... ; )

I will! [nt]

 
 By: amanico : January 3rd, 2020-01:40

Interesting read

 
 By: Jurry : January 3rd, 2020-01:07
May I reciprocate by sharing what the impact is on me as the average viewer of the conversion result? The original photo gives me the impression of an autumn afternoon with the bleak sunlight as it can be right after small rainstorm. I can see a young fam... 

Absolutely...

 
 By: cshimokita : January 3rd, 2020-02:02
subject matter aside, different versions are subject to different interpretations... and just for fun a saturated, contrast-ie, color variation ; ) ...  

Superbly done [nt]

 
 By: Quan : January 3rd, 2020-05:14

Thanks John...

 
 By: cshimokita : January 3rd, 2020-08:15
even more is possible after the b&w conversion... see Blansky's comments below ; ) Casey

I think your technique is fine and as you say there are a lot of ways of doing the conversion bit I would respectfully add...

 
 By: Blansky : January 3rd, 2020-07:49
that since the original image is slightly problematic in that the sky in the top middle is flared and blown out, that it creates more work due to the fact that your eye is drawn upwards, and out of the picture. I did A LOT of burning and dodging in the da... 

Correct...

 
 By: cshimokita : January 3rd, 2020-08:05
and excellent points... in the original I should have waited until the train passed and avoided that reflection off the first carriage. Casey

Absolutely... agree.

 
 By: cshimokita : January 3rd, 2020-09:26
[nt]

Thanks for deep thought

 
 By: Quan : January 3rd, 2020-22:07
to enlighten us