Thanks Gordon for sharing this, and big congrats to member Horoloupe on his top location in HK! Needless to say my vote is for the 5131 (a fairer competition for the 15202 would have been a 5711? ;-) Enjoy.

Jan 15, 2022,16:17 PM
 

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Your vote needed for a showdown !

 
 By: GLau : January 15th, 2022-16:08
5131G vs AP RO green dial - which one do you prefer and why ? Please vote but given this is Patek forum I have home court advantage, right ? 😃 Link to the original post about wristcheck which is a “new pre-owned” dealer in Hong Kong 🇭🇰 www.watchprosit...  

agree with Professsor theorem

 
 By: Gelato Monster : January 16th, 2022-00:54

😂👍👍

 
 By: FabR : January 16th, 2022-01:07

Good suggestion that 5711 would be the perfect piece for a

 
 By: GLau : January 16th, 2022-15:39
showdown with 15202 green ! Which 5711 is most worthy for this fun competition given that the RO green is "limited" ?

Patek worldtime for me

 
 By: Pim : January 15th, 2022-16:44
The WT function and enamel dial are second to none. Absolute grail piece. So that, or a green watch...... yeah

Definitely Cloisonné dials

 
 By: Patekfinity : January 15th, 2022-16:50
Would definitely pick the Patek Cloisonné dials over an AP RO any day…👍. Remember every dial is unique on the Patek versus AP with standard green, blue, salmon, purple, etc colors.

Good point !

 
 By: GLau : January 16th, 2022-15:42
Each 5131 dial is different because each is hand-made and as such is piece unique !

Worldtime for.me

 
 By: @lberti : January 15th, 2022-16:52

Definitely the Patek

 
 By: vitalsigns : January 15th, 2022-16:59
The enamel dial kills any ordinary dial, even a fume dial on a hyped watch Despite the beauty of the enamel dial, it doesn't come across to me a "look-at-me" watch, unlike the AP So it may seem strange, but I think the Patek is much more under the radar t... 

Thanks John for your comments !

 
 By: GLau : January 16th, 2022-15:45
To me both the RO green dial and vibrancy of the 5131 enamel dial are eye-catching. Difference is that less people will know what watch the 5131 is and its significance.

I am with you!

 
 By: amanico : January 16th, 2022-18:26

To have either of these two is a blessing!

 
 By: Time to watch : January 15th, 2022-17:03
My vote is for appreciation and enjoyment of all watches. A case can be made for either piece, but If I had to choose one it would be… Just a sec, doorbell, be right back.

Both are great, and yes the RO is amazing, but...

 
 By: KCLQMULKU : January 15th, 2022-17:12
I dont really think it is fair on the RO to be compared with any 5131 or any PP with enamel! 😆

I'll second that. It's a very convoluted juxtaposition.

 
 By: Ivan5 : January 16th, 2022-00:29
But if pressed, it'd be 5131 by a mile. Never understood why would AP forgo its signature waffle dial on PT version. What a lost opportunity to make this release truly special...

Interesting comment by you Ivan5 relating to the

 
 By: GLau : January 16th, 2022-15:47
waffle/tapestry pattern. It would have been better to have a green tapestry pattern.

the WT anytime any day!

 
 By: Watcholic_id : January 16th, 2022-04:40

The world is my time.

 
 By: Seconds : January 16th, 2022-21:03

Good choice seconds !

 
 By: GLau : January 19th, 2022-15:59
Appreciate it.