Patek 2551 vs 2552 ( versus 3433 )

Sep 14, 2022,22:10 PM
 

Cosmopak recently posted his most wonderful ref 2551 with a stunning dial and a sharp case


Then Aperna posted his 2552 ( the original Flying saucer or disco Volante)

Oahu suggested that both are worthy and should hear in the same post

This got me thinking

What are the differences between 2551 and 2552- both have the same movement the wonderful ref 12-600 Pateks first automatic movement. Totally over engineered - much has n=been written about this movement . Specifically in the archives you can search for Walt Odett;s work as well as Michael Friedberg.

The cases are same but different 

The 2551 has more soft lowing lines on the lug and the case but the ref 2552 has more defined steps on the case giving it a more rugged look






ref 2552 note the definite lines on the case




side on


The ref 2551 on the other hand has sculptured lugs and softer lines on the case






 This has rare target sub dial

Both have two stunning features in common

The movement






ref 12-600 

and the double PP crown

  







So what is the difference between the ref 2551 and 3433

Case is the same 






ref 3433

 But movement is the "upgraded" ref 27-460






cal 27-460 

here is a pic of the 3433  ( same case as 2551) and the 2552 side by side

  






3433 vs 2552 

Thank you for your attention

Julian  



More posts: 255125523433Aston MartincalatravaVolante

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Excellent post, my friend!

 
 By: kcinemod : September 15th, 2022-00:19
2552 for me! 😉

what a surprise :) yours is stunning

 
 By: watch-guy.com : September 15th, 2022-07:37

agree, only charming pieces in your pictures

 
 By: VinnieD : September 15th, 2022-05:33
That first picture shows a very sharp case

Thanks very much

 
 By: watch-guy.com : September 15th, 2022-07:37

Thanks Nico

 
 By: watch-guy.com : September 15th, 2022-07:39

Nice post!

 
 By: KCLQMULKU : September 15th, 2022-07:06
For me it will have to be the 3433 for its dial, bezel, and size.

Both nice watches to wear

 
 By: watch-guy.com : September 15th, 2022-07:39

Why not get both? ;))

 
 By: KCLQMULKU : September 15th, 2022-10:38
I completely agree that either will be amazing to own.

Nice

 
 By: caarl_watcher : September 15th, 2022-09:45
Thanks for the detailed explanation.

Here’s a close-up of mine

 
 By: aperna : September 15th, 2022-17:19
...  

Beautiful, Disco!

 
 By: kcinemod : September 15th, 2022-17:49

Thanks everyone again

 
 By: watch-guy.com : September 15th, 2022-20:33
Hopefully we will see more PP vintage on this site Julian