I have a 5056P and love it.

I love the applied Roman's, the grey dial and the heft of the Platinum case. The moonphase has a subtle beauty that you can't really understand until you see it in person.

I also have a 5146G and I love it just as much as the 5056P

Both beautiful watches and I like them equally.

If I could change one thing, I would like for the 5056P to be 38-40mm in diameter.

I'm also fond of the 5146P but i'm happy with what I have.

💰1729 Marketplace Listings for Patek Philippe›

5056P

By: wso : April 21st, 2009-22:22

Hi all: Being an newbie, could you guys offer me your thoughts on the 5056P compared to other PP annual calendars (both discontinued and still in production). Your advice is most appreciated. Thanks. WSO

I would much prefer either the ........................

By: Topcat30093 : April 21st, 2009-23:57

5146G or 5135G or P The main reason being, that I am not a fan of Roman Numerals on the dial.

I've owned a 5056P for over a year now......

By: karsajid : April 22nd, 2009-07:46

I selected this watch because it was 1. platinum with the signature diamond 2. the gray face with the red dots in the power dial 3. very subtle 4. and a useful and affordable complication. I also have a small wrist, so it was more suitable than the 51xx s...

For most of the same reasons and Roman Numerals.

By: ArthurSG : April 22nd, 2009-21:00

Here's mine for reference. I still think she is a beauty and I find it niceer than the 5146 which I was also considering. I also personally prefer the power reserve indicator on the 5056P better thante 5146 but to each his own. Here's a pic of the movemen...

Patek Philippe