Patek Philippe

Chromatic Fugue
1903

• Show profile
• Show other posts

First impressions of the 5196P

As I previously posted, I swapped a 5107P for this 5196P a few days ago. Some thoughts after a few days on the wrist:

1. It’s the thinnest watch I have ever owned (8mm) but far from the lightest. Particularly with the solid case back, the watch has a nice heft. But because it sits so close to the wrist, it doesn’t have the sometimes-too-noticeable torque I associate with thicker platinum watches.

2. The dial is subtle but amazing. Highlights: the 60 mirrored dots, the 12 mirrored arabics, the interior racetrack on the subdial, and the differently finished surfaces across the main dial.

3. The main reason I had never previously considered this model was a purist’s unease with the mismatch between the small movement and large case (and the consequently high placement of the subdial). But that unease dissipated when I saw the watch in the metal.

It’s as though Patek told its designers, “we’re going to use this legacy movement in a 37mm case, so go out and make the best of that bad situation”—and the designers then not only did their jobs, but created an unexpected work of art in the process. The closest analogy I can think of is the 5070, which also has a movement “too small” for the case, and Patek’s designers created another masterpiece when making the best of that bad situation. In the words of Igor Stravinsky: “The more constraints one imposes, the more one frees one’s self. And the arbitrariness of the constraint serves only to obtain precision of execution.”