Patek Philippe

I was offered a new 5905R for my 3 year old 5164R. Both watches are great, I like them both. I am debating with myself, so any opinions are welcomed. Cheers!

Both have different uses. I have a 5905G and love the watch. I like it better than a 5167 but a 5164r is worth more than the 5905.

I‘d take the 5905r over the 5164r, but the 5164r is currently worth more. Not an easy decision.

The 5905 is very tasteful

Both are great timepieces, I have the 5905P (black dial) and the 5164A. 5905 can be easily dressed down by changing the strap which makes for a more everyday watch. I travel a lot internationally for work so the 5164A is a great dual time zone piece. In t...  

It depends on your personal feelings though, how you love/use your 5164 and what else you have in your collection. Having myself a 5960P and a 5164A, I can perfectly feel the pain of having to make a decision. Good luck!

a trade along with cash for the difference. Naturally if you have the means, then buy a 5905 to enjoy both.