On the basis that I rotate my watches all the time and don't particularly like winders I would go with a manual wind for the reasons you have explained & especially if the movement is visible. If I

Oct 14, 2021,14:31 PM
 

was the kind of person that would wear this most of the time then an automatic would become more compelling. Good luck with your decision.

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Would you rather?

 
 By: Erik1 : October 14th, 2021-13:59
I’ve had as a long term goal to acquire a perpetual calendar chrono but have started thinking whether having a manual wind chrono and perpetual duo could be better on the basis that it allows for watches with a thinner and likely more discrete case size (... 

Which watch?

 
 By: Robert65 : October 14th, 2021-14:28
A Patek PCC is the King's watch. I find occasions to wear it - though it would have to be the correct environment/situation. Manual wind chrono is outrageously appropriate in more circumstances. Tough decision. But I'd go with simply having the King! PCC.... 

Fair enough

 
 By: Erik1 : October 14th, 2021-16:31
I’m not making a decision now so not 100% sure which PCC / PC and Chrono combo I’d get but likely 5270G first gen or 5170J/R and 3940/5940G

On the basis that I rotate my watches all the time and don't particularly like winders I would go with a manual wind for the reasons you have explained & especially if the movement is visible. If I

 
 By: templetowers : October 14th, 2021-14:31
was the kind of person that would wear this most of the time then an automatic would become more compelling. Good luck with your decision.

You said everything: An exceptional PCC or a pc and a chrono duo...

 
 By: amanico : October 14th, 2021-14:35
I would go for the exceptional, especially if it is a 5970P.

Agree...

 
 By: mdg : October 14th, 2021-15:38
...if you can pick up a Patek PCC you are good to go. Otherwise, I'd go for something like a Patek 3940/Lange 1815 Chronograph...best of breed : )

Not bad, not bad...

 
 By: amanico : October 14th, 2021-20:57

I didn’t even realise I wrote it like that - maybe a sign!

 
 By: Erik1 : October 14th, 2021-16:33
I’d most likely get the 5270G first gen as I really like that dial but let’s see when/if the time comes!

I understand the 5970 vs 5270 debate

 
 By: Robert65 : October 14th, 2021-16:41
However, either one is a lifetime achievement. Only folks on a forum like this even can appreciate the fine/minute differences or preferences between those two references. The rest of the world doesn't care. Either of those PCC are ONE AND DONE!!

Just got the 5270P a moth back….

 
 By: Watches_passion : October 16th, 2021-14:52
And i can tell you… it is an exceptional beauty, not to say a picasso like piece of art. ...  

Congratulations!

 
 By: Erik1 : October 16th, 2021-15:50
Is it something you’d wear daily (a few times a week)?