Definitely the 5164/1A

Mar 03, 2019,14:16 PM
 

It's better proportioned. The 5968 is a bit too large and fat IMO. Not to mention the date window at 3 O'Clock makes the dial less balanced. And don't forget that the 5164A has already been out for 8 years, and it will probably be discontinued soon. Selling now will definitely cause you regret in the future!




More posts: 51645164A5968aquanaut

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Patek Philippe 5164a vs 5968a

 
 By: Stek : March 3rd, 2019-12:48
Good eventing to all, Start of a luxury problem. I just bought an aquanaut 5164a but yesterday in Geneva I visited the Patek store. Heaven for all Patek enthausiasts. In the store a had the luck to wear a lot of Patek’s I’m interested in. One of the piece...  

Grats! Beauty is in the eye of the beholder....

 
 By: drg : March 3rd, 2019-12:57
Unfortunately, only you can answer that. Also, welcome. 🍻

A little help..

 
 By: Stek : March 3rd, 2019-12:59
Thanks for welcoming me and you’re very wright although a little experience regarding these watches will be helpful....πŸ˜„

Okay

 
 By: Stek : March 3rd, 2019-13:04
Tnx. Difficult decision to makes with such nice pieces....πŸ˜¬πŸ˜„

Only you can answer that question

 
 By: 1WatchMan : March 3rd, 2019-13:06
I believe there's not a right/wrong decision there. In my case, I wouldn't let my 5164A go for any other Aquanaut. Perfect proportions on my wrist, comfortable and versatile like hell, useful complication, sporty enough to take it to the pool in summer an... 

Same

 
 By: Stek : March 3rd, 2019-13:13
That is the excact the same reason for to by the 5164a. Dual time zone for traveling handy for means the measurements as well. There was however something in me that said......

Re

 
 By: Stek : March 4th, 2019-01:27
Unfortunately no stock, only show material...πŸ˜¬πŸ˜„

Look wise 5968A wins it for me, the next question is the usefulness of a complication

 
 By: Poky : March 3rd, 2019-13:46
If I had the choice, I would go for 5968A even if I don't really have much use for a chronometer. I have seen 5968A in the grey market going for more than double the retail price at present. That is also something to consider.

You mean you have a choice between the 5164 or the 5968???

 
 By: Clueless_Collector : March 3rd, 2019-13:47
if so, I suggest 5968a first πŸ˜‰

βœ…

 
 By: Mikesr  : March 3rd, 2019-14:14
Grab the tray and run. Lol

πŸ˜‚ [nt]

 
 By: Stek : March 4th, 2019-01:28

Definitely the 5164/1A

 
 By: Signo : March 3rd, 2019-14:16
It's better proportioned. The 5968 is a bit too large and fat IMO. Not to mention the date window at 3 O'Clock makes the dial less balanced. And don't forget that the 5164A has already been out for 8 years, and it will probably be discontinued soon. Selli...  

πŸ‘πŸ»

 
 By: Stek : March 4th, 2019-01:29
Thanks, makes the choice easy! πŸ˜„

Good question.

 
 By: @WatchesandWristshots : March 3rd, 2019-15:56
The size of the watch on your own wrist usually answers the question. The answer for me is 5164A. Personally I wouldn't want my watch to be larger. If you can 'handle' them both you can consider the functions. Do you prefer a Chrono or a Dual Time? Also; ... 

Market speculation aside...

 
 By: keks : March 3rd, 2019-16:18
I find the 5164 far more proportionate and balanced. The 5968 is very cool as well and there is naturally a novelty bias as well as secondary market bias. However if we set that aside and assume both cost and are worth the same in dollars then easily 5164... 

I can help you.

 
 By: Wristenthusiast : March 3rd, 2019-19:20
I’ve been searching for both as I refuse to pay the crazy grey market. Get both, and I will buy one off you. I would prefer 5164 but would go 5968 too. I’m serious.

Okay thanks [nt]

 
 By: Stek : March 4th, 2019-01:36

It’s amazing they had these in stock

 
 By: descartes1 : March 3rd, 2019-20:06
I have been waiting for a 5164a for over a year PS - No wrong choice here

Thanks to all helping me out making my choice.

 
 By: Stek : March 4th, 2019-06:31
I have chosen the 5164a. Thanks for helping out! ...  

Beautiful!

 
 By: Greenwatch : March 5th, 2019-15:43
Welcome to the club! ...  

Congratulations! Very nice choice! [nt]

 
 By: @WatchesandWristshots : March 6th, 2019-16:07

I’m wearing my 5164a since 2013 with a lot of Joy and satisfaction and I was definitely not considering to let it go when the chronograph had been released.

 
 By: cayenne1200 : March 6th, 2019-10:12
But after having had the chance to try out the 5968a in real I needed to add that to my collection as well. Both watches are similar and different at the same time and I’m wearing both regularly. I could not make a judgement between both.

5968a

 
 By: Stek : March 6th, 2019-10:58
Okay, so I have to get one myself ....πŸ˜„πŸ˜„πŸ‘πŸ» Let’s go for it! ...  

Great pair! [nt]

 
 By: @WatchesandWristshots : March 6th, 2019-16:08

5968A with Orange Strap ...

 
 By: Mean Solar Time : March 6th, 2019-18:57
... would be my choice. Lol ... I forgot to set the watch ahead 3 days! ...  

Very cool and beautiful

 
 By: Stek : March 6th, 2019-23:22
πŸ‘πŸ»πŸ‘πŸ»πŸ‘πŸ»