5127

Dec 01, 2018,06:41 AM
 

5127 wears much smaller than the 5296. 5296 wears like a 40mm. 5127 also has the traditional sized font on the dial not the super big print used on the new models and the 5296. The 5127 was always a very brisk seller when in production and seen as a big improvement over the scratch magnet wide bezel 5107. The crown guards add a style flow to the whole watch.

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

5127R vs. 5296R

 
 By: JohnFM : November 27th, 2018-18:15
These are my two favorite Calatravas and I'm wondering which you prefer. I know this has been asked before but I can't help myself ;-) Sorry for the image size variation. The 5127R is 37mm, the 5296R 38mm. Thanks. John ...  

5127

 
 By: Vcf.camper : November 27th, 2018-18:38
For thr scallop lugs. The other one is too generic looking imo

5127...

 
 By: vitalsigns : November 27th, 2018-18:40
Very sensual piece, and with the crown guards, almost wears like 38mm. No scalloped lugs, but the 5127 does have wonderfully curved lugs and bezel. Cheers, John

5127 :-)

 
 By: sham1 : November 27th, 2018-18:51
The smaller size is always a better bet for a dress watch not to mention the case design is rounder and has softer lines.

5127...

 
 By: SRG : November 27th, 2018-20:05
The like the more rounded features of the case.

5127 but is a close call [nt]

 
 By: agyzace : November 27th, 2018-20:33

5127

 
 By: henryrover : November 27th, 2018-22:04
The case profile is just irresistible..... It is a dominant factor for my choice of 5110 among various worldtime models

First one [nt]

 
 By: jomni1 : November 27th, 2018-23:24

Never had the 5127, but id go for that Calatrava because of the crown guards and its a screw down crown.

 
 By: geross : November 28th, 2018-04:02
More water resistant. And its slightly smaller at 37 mm. in diameter. More charming. My opinion. Geross.

Thanks for all the input

 
 By: JohnFM : November 28th, 2018-08:09
I thought this would be a much closer call, but the 5127R wins by unanimous decision!

5296...

 
 By: LS : November 28th, 2018-15:15
I like the flat polished bezel. And I think a dress watch looks better without crown guards. But I am splitting hairs, here, they are both fantastic watches.

Gee, now you tell me you like the 5296 ...

 
 By: JohnFM : November 28th, 2018-17:21
... after I had given up on it ;-) I agree, it's very nice and probably looks wonderful in person at 38mm -- very understated and simple.

5127

 
 By: watch-er : December 1st, 2018-06:41
5127 wears much smaller than the 5296. 5296 wears like a 40mm. 5127 also has the traditional sized font on the dial not the super big print used on the new models and the 5296. The 5127 was always a very brisk seller when in production and seen as a big i...