I have a smaller wrist and it’s fine. It does wear bigger than the case size (37mm) though. I think this is a result of the wide lug width and flat profile. My preference is for smaller watches in the 36-37 mm range, but I don’t find the watch too big at all.
I remember that the 5196p wasn't a very popular model for a while after its release, partly because the dial was so shiny. However, after more than 10 years, I think it is reconsidering the unique charm that only this model has.