It's the hands and lumination

Dec 30, 2020,19:14 PM
 

The way the lume is designed and placed on the dial is not pleasant to me. Also the the hour hands and minute hands are way too short. I hate how the minute track is inside the hour markers; Making the watch dial not in proportion. While I understand it is a vintage re-issue, Omega could update the look just a little. On the case back, Omega should have put an air plane on one and a boat on the other Seamaster 1948. Maybe have the plane/boat in gold on the rotor.
For me, the JLC Geophysic 1958 re-issue is a much better looking watch; Almost perfect when it comes to 3 center handers vintage style/re-issue


More posts: Seamaster

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Omega’s might 💪🏿💪🏿

 
 By: Lankysudanese : December 29th, 2020-11:05
My recent poor experience with Rolex watches and Rolex servicing (see post on Rolex forum if you aren’t put off by bad customer service) and the off-hand comparison of omega watches to “5 dollar plastic watches” by the Rolex service center watchmaker, alo...  

So now you're into "5-dollar watches"... 😂

 
 By: India Whiskey Charlie : December 29th, 2020-11:14

apparently😂😂.

 
 By: Lankysudanese : December 29th, 2020-11:18
That is gonna make my accountant happy

Same here: #1 and #7 👍

 
 By: India Whiskey Charlie : December 29th, 2020-11:22

I’m not saying that any of these examples are perfect, but each showcase omega pushing the envelope in one way or another...

 
 By: Lankysudanese : December 29th, 2020-11:37
...(including the controversial ‘value for money’ metric)

The design is one thing...

 
 By: India Whiskey Charlie : December 29th, 2020-11:38
Add the ultra ridiculous price into the equation and you have a cheap looking expensive watch.

Pretty much, yes...👍

 
 By: India Whiskey Charlie : December 29th, 2020-12:11

All my watches are Omegas (I'm obviously biased😂)

 
 By: myles721 : December 29th, 2020-11:38
But the point is bigger than Rolex alone...while I think Omega is undervalued (but catching up VERY quickly) it is galling when certain (not Rolex actually) brands get away with sub standard products with excuses like”they are hand made”, “don’t look to c... 

Not forgetting creativity ...

 
 By: Cpt Scarlet : December 29th, 2020-11:43
Great value at just $5 ;-)) ...  

Touché...touché

 
 By: Lankysudanese : December 29th, 2020-11:47

What gets me about Rolex🤬

 
 By: mjcruiser : December 29th, 2020-11:54
Of all the top tier brands brands; they are the only one to not offer exhibition backs. They don’t do the exotic finishing that we have come to expect from fine watchmakers!

Totally agree with you there...

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : December 29th, 2020-13:05

I think they are both great brand but must admit I like how omega offer more choices of dials and complications. I just got my first Omega last week and I LOVE it.

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : December 29th, 2020-13:03
Movement technology and chronometry are up there with the best of the industry. I would not be surprised if I was to add another omega to the collection in 2021! Who knows...lol

You're singing . . .

 
 By: Dr No : December 29th, 2020-14:25
. . . my song. Oh, and you knew . . . Next up: O-M-E-G-A? . . . . . . this was coming ;-) . . .

The fine things

 
 By: Weems@8 : December 29th, 2020-16:37
Omega is a brand that goes for detailed watches i experienced with my own Seamaster. I was not known with the brand before i bought my Seamaster. I red some comments on communities about a Seamaster with a failure in the dial and bazel. The outlining was ... 

Omega Seamaster 1948

 
 By: Treiz1337 : December 29th, 2020-17:52
I am actually selling mine to make way for a new acquisition.

Because of any design flaws, or just because your taste has changed.

 
 By: Lankysudanese : December 29th, 2020-20:53
IMHO that particular piece is the perfect amalgamation of vintage looks and modern engineering (with the chronometry and ruggedness that comes along)

It's the hands and lumination

 
 By: Treiz1337 : December 30th, 2020-19:14
The way the lume is designed and placed on the dial is not pleasant to me. Also the the hour hands and minute hands are way too short. I hate how the minute track is inside the hour markers; Making the watch dial not in proportion. While I understand it i... 

I get your point and your warranted dissatisfaction, but things are not that simple. I once had two different issues with a brand new Patek. The Paris Boutique first told me that I did something wrong...

 
 By: amanico : December 29th, 2020-23:15
They didn't say it twice... Now to say that Patek watches are worse or better than other watches from other brands, I wouldn't say so. There are people who just should do another job. Period. But you are right, there is a life outside Rolex, Patek, AP and... 

I think that we are agreeing.

 
 By: Lankysudanese : December 30th, 2020-00:48
Any cursory YouTube search of the words Rolex, Patek nautilus, Royal oak will yield all the top watch YouTubers offering alternatives to said watches. Being someone who’s owned 4 Rolex watches so far (2 SS sports, 2 datejust), and two of those needing ser... 

You’ve but the nail on the head.

 
 By: Lankysudanese : December 30th, 2020-12:14
I believe that they are starting to change their approach. More push for the constellation, Tresor and deville lines. Also, not sure if it was intentional/manufactured scarcity or what, but I didn’t see a single manual wind speedmaster during a quick visi... 

You absolutely have a point, Hussam

 
 By: George Gently : December 30th, 2020-02:15
What impresses me indeed, is the catalogue of Omega, which offers almost everything one could want. Enjoy yours Regards, George

Omega vs Rolex

 
 By: Cookies : December 30th, 2020-05:35
It’s such a complex issue, by era or by price history. In the 90’s to early 2000’s they used many ETA movements, so the comparison is likely more similar to a Tudor today. But in terms of finishing, I think their cases are better finished than the rough e... 

So well said!...

 
 By: myles721 : December 30th, 2020-06:04
Scarcity vs brand perception vs performance.

I have many watches from both brands and appreciate them for what they are. Hard to argue one is better than the other...

 
 By: holdemchamp1225 : December 30th, 2020-14:33
The one thing I can say that favors Omega at the moment is availability compared to Rolex who seem to be vacuumed up, regardless of the model (except for 2 tone and certain ladies models). I do agree that Omega has been more daring and taking risks with t... 

What a measured, calm and poignant response.

 
 By: Lankysudanese : December 30th, 2020-22:31
Happy New Year to you, Sir.