I've had the alligator nubuck on it for so long, but I don't see it as the best match. And I do have another aftermarket strap which was gifted to me a while back and which I like very much, but that I never tried on. However, I have been awaiting the arrival of a JRousseau strap I had ordered, so I'd like to try that one first. We'll see. In all cases, thank you for showcasing such a wide range of cool straps!