Montblanc Villeret 1858 Tachymeter: 2016 or 2018?

Apr 16, 2018,12:27 PM
 

So close, so different at the same time. 







44 mm polished case, without beveled lugs, on your left / 40 mm brushed case, beveled and thinner lugs on your right. 

Both mono pusher Chronographs, but one is located in the crown, while the other is at 2 o clock. 

Pear shaped crown on the left, traditional crown on the right. 

Same dial architecture, but not the same color. 

Both of them house a beautiful movement, finely decorated, but the one on the left, the 13.21, is more compact than the one on the right, the 16.29.

These are deep differences, but does that justify to get both of them? This is the question which is still in my mind, three months after discovering the Green Brother... 

And you? 

Best,

Nicolas


More posts: 1858 CollectionCollection Villeret

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

That would be a hard choice to make.

 
 By: Bill : April 16th, 2018-12:32
I would have to see it in the flesh. Your pictures make it look almost vintage. Very cool.

Villeret 13.21 movement is . . .

 
 By: Dr No : April 16th, 2018-12:46
. . . less compact? I thought it was more, Nicolas. Confused, Art

LOL. Good analogy! [nt]

 
 By: amanico : April 16th, 2018-14:38

I am slightly bothered by the truncated numerals on the Green dial.

 
 By: M4 : April 16th, 2018-13:06
Maybe I'm just spoiled by the dial of the blue version, which is near perfect. M4

Rumor-ish

 
 By: Mostel : April 16th, 2018-16:45
heard from a VERY SERIOUS COLLECTOR that the earlier versions have better finishing... these would be dated in the very early blue dials... why? Once MB saw the popularity (let's face it--they never had a hit on their hands) they increased the production ... 

I would think so! [nt]

 
 By: traineract : April 18th, 2018-21:14

May be for a Montblanc Collector both

 
 By: Walter2 : April 17th, 2018-01:32
For a Mulltibrand-collector one is enough. I love more the green one. Best Walter

Just curious...

 
 By: traineract : April 17th, 2018-04:09
The 13.21 is the one inside the 44mm version right? The movement is more compact and yet the case size is bigger?

Ahhh

 
 By: traineract : April 17th, 2018-09:08
Okay now that makes sense. Thanks nico!

Not your fault nico

 
 By: traineract : April 18th, 2018-07:26
My bad for the assumptions!

Green for me.

 
 By: VMM : April 17th, 2018-07:51
Mainly because of the size. As we already have discussed it would be nice to see it with the pusher in the crown like it's big brother. Vte

So difficult to choose...

 
 By: KMII : April 17th, 2018-20:29
I like the size and case of the 1858 Monopusher better but prefer the dial colour of the 1858 Tachymeter. As to movements, both are finished to the same level, so... So are you tempted to get the other one, too?

Love the green. But enamel is the way to go.

 
 By: Arie - Mr Orange : April 18th, 2018-07:17
btw This 44 mm blue monster is saying hi! ...  

;-) [nt]

 
 By: Arie - Mr Orange : April 18th, 2018-08:44

Yes, too cool! [nt]

 
 By: amanico : April 18th, 2018-09:50

I would agree :)

 
 By: KMII : April 18th, 2018-08:26
Enamel like Robinโ€™s is certainly the way to go!

+1 [nt]

 
 By: Arie - Mr Orange : April 18th, 2018-12:24

Both beautiful

 
 By: Dave G : April 20th, 2018-04:02
But I would pick the 40mm green version. Dave

I own some 44mm watches

 
 By: Dave G : April 20th, 2018-04:23
but I have decided they are a bit too big for me. Size is the primary driver.

Blue and nothing but the Blue my friend !!

 
 By: Horology75 : May 1st, 2018-17:31
The monopusher on the crown does it and that blue gives you that sensational feeling ) If I would have the option and the money Iโ€™d go for the blue 44mm