JoeJ
29
I had a similar choice
Between the MUT moon (silver face) and an A Lange Sohne Saxonia Automatic.
Can’t speak for the Patek but after putting both on, i just felt the presence of the Lange a lot more. The JLC felt like a toy watch in comparison. I know that might be controversial in the JLC room but just my experience!
More posts:
Need your advice. Which one will you guys choose?
[Seller information removed also from this thread — FabR] ...
Is it white gold or steel?
I just put that JLC on a watch list. Steel. Your experience is useful.
Another vote for the JLC.
Both are classic choices, but I personally find the JLC a more compelling choice.
Peculiar choice of hands
The new date hand has a counterweight that the previous model lacked, for a good reason. The counterweight obstructs the moon phase view every 12th to 20th of the month.
I would go for jlc
I just got the 36 mill one and I love it. Would even have loved it more if it was blue dial Kev
On paper: JLC. On the wrist: PP. Id take the patek for the more refined details.
Yet if you like moonphases, the jlc is really cool!
JLC
I have tried on that blue MUT Moon and it’s stunning. If I didn’t already have the silver dial, I would have bought it.
VERY DIFFERENT pieces...
except that they are both "elegant." The 5127G is 37mm with gently sloped bezel (which WILL show more scarring) and with date, making this IMO a "business" watch, whereas the MUT Moon is 39mm, has a steeply-sloped bezel (less prone to scratches) and has d...
I had a similar choice
Between the MUT moon (silver face) and an A Lange Sohne Saxonia Automatic. Can’t speak for the Patek but after putting both on, i just felt the presence of the Lange a lot more. The JLC felt like a toy watch in comparison. I know that might be controversi...
Agreed
The white gold definitely had more heft..but everything about the watch felt elevated…the winding of the rotor felt smoother and more solid, the finishing was next level, and the German silver dial had more sparkle.
