mirador
86
Awesome
I feel the AMI has the better dial but the crowns on the MCM are superior to those on the AMI - it's a draw.
One thing that does catch my eye though, is the location of the Date function. It looks slightly out of place at Three O'Clock, especially on the MCM together with number 16 on the outer-dial; the NSA has the same location of the Date but it doesn't seem to create a clash of numbers. Still wouldn't say No to either one though, real beauties.
MCM vs AMI
No, it’s not a Roman number… It’s time for round one! The Master Compressor Memovox versus the Aston Martin I!!! Here are my personal opinions about the two. Common basics: Engine; Cal 918, 260 parts, 28800 vph, 45 h power reserve. Functions; Hour, minute...
Interesting comparison Blomman.
The AM 1 in Titanium will get some more stars as the contact and the weight on the wrist make it very comfortable. I like it so much and have my preference in this comparison. Cheers, Patrickh
TI gets more stars?
That sounds great Patrickh! Is it the grey dial or maybe the AMI-R green? I have always been torn about the green AMI ti. I do understand the connection with British Racing Green, but I am not sure about having a green watch. The dial is stunning – especi...
As you wish.
The very first one delivered in Paris, and an every day pleaure to wear and hear too since get-up. Best, patrickh...
Thanks Patrickh!
The grey dial really gives it a different character than the black ss one. Looks great! Best Blomman
I needed this review about a year ago. LOL.
When I was trying to decide on the perfect alarm watch for me, this review would have been very helpful -- or perhaps it would have just confused me more, as you make a good case for both. Hey, at least I was able to narrow choices down to within a single...
Sorry I am late... Respo
But as you said – maybe it would only confuse more… There are a lot more to say about these two wonderful watches! D id you go for any of them or are you still holing of? Best Blomman
Hy Blomman
In the end I went for the Tribute to Polaris '65 when the opportunity arose to get one. Even if I cannot settle on a Reverso, I was able to settle on a JLC alarm. respo
Ah, the Paris boutique edition!
Actually, I was little bit upset with JLC after that one. Because when I ordered my two Polaris I didn’t know about the Paris boutique edition. Later I heard a rumour about a third version, so I asked JLC about the third one, and they say there are only t...
Were you dealing with an AD or JLC Boutique?
I have found that many ADs simply do not have all the information about JLC watches, which is why this forum is so helpful in so many ways. Of course, the PBE was impossible to order from anywhere other than the PB (and I had some Moderated help with mine...
AD
But I had them call JLC while I was standing right next to the phone… Yes, I realised that later, and it turned out to a good thing anyway. But, when you ask a straight question, you are expecting a straight answer… About the Memos, thank you ...
A very useful review, Blomman --
Perhaps you would throw in a few lines comparing the sound qualities of the two?
Happy you liked it, Sery!
Concerning the sound of the two, it’s very difficult to say. Especially when I am no sound expert, but I try; Both have a fairly strong sound, stronger then a minute repeater. They have the same rhythm since it’s the same Cal 918 and both are ...
Very nice job, Blomman
When I think about what Black Memovox to add in my collection, comes to my mind the Black Memovox housing the manual Cal 914. And also the Vintage Polaris 65... As for the MC Memovox, I had it in 2002, and sold it in 2004, because of this 3rd crown at 10,...
Well Nicolas…
There will always be one that haunts us in our dreams! If it’s not the vintage Polaris 65 or the MM cal 914, it will be something else… And I bet that when you have them all – if you don’t have the MCM you will regret it! At least just to make sure to clo...
The Memovox Cal 914 won't be that hard to find,
At the contrary of the Polaris 65, but I'm still working on getting one... And I won't give up! Best, Nicolas
informative review!
Between the two, I prefer the MC Memovox, I like the 10atm water resistance. But if I could go out today and buy one of the two, already owning a different MC, I would probably branch out and get the Amvox I. and wear the Compressor when there's a chance ...
Hello PeaceFrog!
To have one of each would be the perfect solution! Which one did you pick? I only have experience of the MCM but I am very curious on the other two MC’s! J Best Blomman
forced to make do with an EWC!
I swear, if there was an Extreme Compressor with chronograph, alarm and 2d time zone, I would never covet another watch, ever. That would be my perfect solution. I guess I like JLCs too much, I couldn't stand to wear one and leave the other(s) at home! If...
PeaceFrog, you are like my twin
I feel the same way about the EWC, and if it were to have an alarm it would be more than perfect for me. I also considered trading mine in for the EWA, but decided against that, which I am absolutely positive was the right decision. Your Evil Twin, respo
one day I will turn around downtown
and there it will be on your wrist, a horological doppelganger... This close encounter of the extreme kind will require celebratory beverage consumption, you realize?!?!
LOL. I can't wait. I'll be on the lookout!
Or perhaps we should schedule a WIS getogether. respo
EWC, nice choice PeaceFrog!
Not much of a chronograph man my self – but it’s a strong piece! The EWA I am very curious about… Best Blomman
Nice, Blomman
Thanks for this nicely done and very informative review. Actually I am looking into the MCM. I absolutely love the Memovox complication and want to have a more sporty watch. In that case the MCM seems to be a good choice, right. Cheers!
Thanks Maverik!
Both are very sporty, the AMI more classic Memovox than the MCM. But I think if you want a sports watch that you actually can use as a sport watch then the MCM is to prefer. Best Blomman
these two are ionic watch...
... love to see your beautiful review. Blomman, well done and thanks for sharing. stefan
Thanks Stefan!
For your kind words. I know you are more towards the dressier watches. But now when you got bitten by the Vox Pox – maybe it’s time to look into sports section..? Best Blomman
Well, if it’s a sporty memovox you are after…
I would say the AMI , considering your previous choice of watches. Especially as you earlier mentioned that you would like to have a black dialled one in your collection. A watch I am very curious about is the Extreme World Alarm. But I don’t know if that...
Awesome
I feel the AMI has the better dial but the crowns on the MCM are superior to those on the AMI - it's a draw. One thing that does catch my eye though, is the location of the Date function. It looks slightly out of place at Three O'Clock, especially on the ...
Thanks Mirador!
Yes, two beauties! As Nicolas pointed out the other day – if the watches was perfect, it would be boring… Best Blomman