With regards to craftsmanship, I think MB&F would be considered above Urwerk.

Dec 05, 2020,07:57 AM
 

The MB&F movements are well finished with black polish and anglage, where Urwerks look more machine finished. MB&F even gives you a custom box that's specific to the model, there was a post on this a while ago if you want to search for it. But for watches like these, I think the only way to decide is to try them on yourself.


For some other brands to look at:
Akrivia
Christophe Claret
Greubel Forsey
DeBethune
Romain Guathier
HYT
Open dial variants of some watches like the Vingt-8


More posts: Christophe ClaretGreubel ForseyHYTUrwerkVingt-8Voutilainen

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

"Steampunk" / technical watch: MB&F vs. Urwerk vs. ?

 
 By: nafetS : December 5th, 2020-04:15
Dear all, one type of watch I've wanted to add to my collection for a long time, is a steampunkish watch like the Urwerk UR-105 or the MB&F Horological Machine No9 (added pictures taken from the manufacturer's websites). Those are just examples, thoug...  

vs LAURENT FERRIER X URWERK LR-UR 2

 
 By: patrickh : December 5th, 2020-04:43
monochrome-watches.com ...  

my pleasure to contribute to your post.

 
 By: patrickh : December 5th, 2020-06:02
I hope you will find your Dream "technical" watch.

Both amazing and very cool watches but also both different.

 
 By: Watchonthewrists : December 5th, 2020-04:50
The Urwerk would the most wearable one . I have seen them both and tried them on the wrist . There both on top of the game and you can’t go wrong with any of them imho. I own a UR103 and have had great customer service experience. Don’t own a MB

Like you said the design of the UR is a bit more wearable imo.

 
 By: Watchonthewrists : December 5th, 2020-06:57
But dont get me wrong , i would love to own the HM9 , its so amazing and cool . Def a piece of wrist art

Interestingly enough, I had that MB

 
 By: Obeezy : December 5th, 2020-06:14
For me, I didn’t like all that wrist jockeying. I own neither brand, although my interest has been piqued by Urwerk recently so that may change. I’d go for the Urwerk. IMO it seems less gimmicky than the MB

Makes much more sense now :-)

 
 By: nafetS : December 5th, 2020-09:14
And yes, you're right. The HM9 could maybe be a bit too gimmicky long term.

vs david candaux vs greubel forsey

 
 By: patrickh : December 5th, 2020-06:56
should also be considered for pure technical watch, imho.

I've seen and played with both for an extended period of time. I prefer the MB&F for look and execution. It does not take away from the Urwerk as I think it is also an uber cool watch...

 
 By: holdemchamp1225 : December 5th, 2020-07:28
but you asked us to choose so it would be the MB&F here. Plus, it wears better on my wrist as well 👍

With regards to craftsmanship, I think MB&F would be considered above Urwerk.

 
 By: jleno : December 5th, 2020-07:57
The MB&F movements are well finished with black polish and anglage, where Urwerks look more machine finished. MB&F even gives you a custom box that's specific to the model, there was a post on this a while ago if you want to search for it. But for... 

Well said J 👍

 
 By: holdemchamp1225 : December 5th, 2020-07:58

Really hope I can try both brands on the wrist at some point!

 
 By: jleno : December 5th, 2020-08:35
Have only seen them at a distance up until now

Ok, thank you. Interesting to hear about the difference in finishing.

 
 By: nafetS : December 5th, 2020-09:19
Of course, I'll have to find out myself. But as I've mentioned, retailers are far away and in different places. I want to be prepared as good as possible to not have to travel several times to make up my mind.

When I hear "steampunk" I think Vianney Halter...

 
 By: CR : December 5th, 2020-09:46
... so I'd suggest checking out all of VH's offerings as well. Good luck!

Big +1 👍

 
 By: holdemchamp1225 : December 5th, 2020-09:47

Agreed

 
 By: Spencer Karrington : December 6th, 2020-06:56

I think that it is about 80,000 for the perpetual calender but I have sometimes seen it cheaper but that is rare

 
 By: Spencer Karrington : December 6th, 2020-06:55
He also just released a new watch with louis erard at a much more affordable price

I like this one. Very technical, very different.

 
 By: brauner : December 5th, 2020-11:02
De Bethune DB28, credit see pic ...  

👍

 
 By: brauner : December 5th, 2020-21:31