You got a point

Jul 02, 2020,00:34 AM
 

Perhaps at this price point which is closing in on a price of a Perpetual Calendar Chronograph from Patek, or even Gauthier's own Logical One, and there are many other options. This watch has no complication so it's a matter of whether the finishing quality is high enough to warrant this. In the manufacturer website, it was claimed that 250 hours of labor just to finish the movement meticulously.
I am new in this but I think there are some horological time piece that is close to this price range without complication, just really excellent finishing. Is that RW Smith or something and I think Grebuey Forsey's own time only watch is also around this price range, with arguably less finishing work?

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Romain Gauthier New Skeletonized Micro Rotor

 
 By: benlee338 : July 1st, 2020-19:43
Don't think this has been discussed yet. What do members hear think of this piece? Personally I think it looks amazing. Although the pricing is giving me a bit of pause... Link to Hodinkee article : ...  

I agree on both counts

 
 By: sham1 : July 1st, 2020-19:47
especially the high pricing bit! I always ask myself what else can one buy for that amount of money

+1

 
 By: jleno : July 1st, 2020-20:54
Great finishing, but for the money I'd also want a significant complication.

We think alike

 
 By: Mr.Gatsby : July 1st, 2020-21:40
With that kinda money I’ll buy a 911 ;-)

not just what else can be bought, but what else can be supported...

 
 By: avseg : July 2nd, 2020-01:58
I go out of my way to support independents, but 250 hours of finishing or not, this is a lot of support RG is asking! I also am wary of RG customer service. So it's not just what else I could be buying, but what else I could be supporting.

Good point!

 
 By: sham1 : July 2nd, 2020-05:00
And well done for supporting the independents. I am glad these Romain Gauthers are being produced in small quantities or they might remain in stock for a while

Ben, I really like the look of it

 
 By: Mr.Gatsby : July 1st, 2020-21:39
And I’m sure it’s gonna be an outstanding watch on the wrist at 39.5mm. The price however is grossly overstated. If it is anywhere between 50-80K CHF I think I would take a serious look at it. At the current list, my options are plenty. Although not a par... 

You got a point

 
 By: benlee338 : July 2nd, 2020-00:34
Perhaps at this price point which is closing in on a price of a Perpetual Calendar Chronograph from Patek, or even Gauthier's own Logical One, and there are many other options. This watch has no complication so it's a matter of whether the finishing quali... 

From what I've seen, RG finishing looks top-notch...

 
 By: mdg : July 1st, 2020-22:05
...but the logo looks straight out of MS Word and the curved underline is not attractive. He needs to hire a decent graphic designer (I would do it but not sure if I'm decent) : )

IMHO

 
 By: benlee338 : July 2nd, 2020-00:35
Among the very best. The fonts looks ok to me. You can volunteer, LOL.

Surely very nice to look at but...

 
 By: Mike H : July 1st, 2020-23:07
...regretfully I have to agree with all that has been said by others here. At least for me with my limitations, the biggest complication with this one is... the price and I much prefer other complications in a watch 😉.

That's the reason

 
 By: benlee338 : July 2nd, 2020-00:36
for my hesitation. I will wait for videos of the watch to come out. Based on just rendered pictures, it's hard to judge.

Its a fantastic looking watch .

 
 By: Watchonthewrists : July 2nd, 2020-01:32
Especially with a rose gold case but like you i think the price is a bit high

well done

 
 By: avseg : July 2nd, 2020-01:49
The "skeletonization" of this is really well done and in many ways the design feels more balanced than the original Insight Micro-Rotor. The other thing I appreciate is that skeleton watches often become very hard to read because the dial is often comprom... 

I was corresponding with a fellow member about how hairsprings should have an overcoil for best chronometry,

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : July 2nd, 2020-03:32
and he was pointing out how some very high-end watches don't have them. Two examples that don't are Roman Gauthier and Roger W Smith! Odd stuff, if anyone knows why, please share. It does add something to the conversation, though. I do love the finishing ... 

Hi my friend, I think I agree with you...

 
 By: Mike H : July 2nd, 2020-12:44
...that is purely Logical Leaving aside the price issue I agree that this Skeletonized Micro Rotor is really nice but... for me the Romain Gauthier's DNA lies fully in the Logical One

+1 Mike. Fully agree 😉 [nt]

 
 By: holdemchamp1225 : July 2nd, 2020-13:05

I do like the watch, and every time I’ve met RG I’ve been more and more impressed.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : July 3rd, 2020-06:10
I am curious to hear counter thoughts on RG, as there seems to be several here who have reservations on the brand. As to this watch, I am with others in terms of not being able to get past the price point. If given the choice I would be going for a used L... 

many reservations, unfortunately

 
 By: avseg : July 5th, 2020-12:08
Let me state again that I've gone out of my way to support independents; doing so is largely the reason I began collecting watches in the first place. So it's extremely frustrating even to consider publicly reporting a bad experience with an independent. ...