It had been mangled by some outside watchmaker

May 25, 2018,11:50 AM
 

So, it could be quite a lot to repair that.

Much more than just repairing the original issue.

  login to reply
Comments: view entire thread

F.P. Journe Repetition Souverain sold for $87.5k at Sotheby's yesterday.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : May 25th, 2018-04:12
So the watch was not chiming correctly and so was in need of service. Does anyone know what that service might cost (estimate, roughly)? Just wondering if this was a deal for the buyer or not so much. On other Independents there was also a MB&F Legacy Mac...

A service for a Minute repeater might be several k

 
 By: piccolochimico (aka dsgalaxy1) : May 25th, 2018-04:57
The price is half of the MSRP, thus it's attractive, the main issue is how damaged is the movement. Anyway, those auction houses are selling everything, no matter the conditions (i'm referring to vintage frankenwatches!)

So true… buyer beware ! [nt]

 
 By: Cpt Scarlet : May 25th, 2018-06:09

Jay, I saw that when I checked results last nite

 
 By: Joepny : May 25th, 2018-06:30
Didn’t have time to follow the live auction. I thought I saw a lot of lots that were passed. Or maybe the results page was not updated yet. I was thinking of doing a post about it on my IG.

Yes. On first look my impression was the same.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : May 25th, 2018-09:28
There was another RO Perpetual too, I thought you might have followed that one.

I saw that RO QP

 
 By: Joepny : May 25th, 2018-11:37
The white dial, an older movement without the leap year indicator. Sotheby’s had it as circa 2000 but it is a much older watch, probably from early 1990s. Lots of wear on the watch. I thought the final price was very good considering it had no papers and ...

Right, but could that be a $10k service or $20k?

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : May 25th, 2018-09:22
I have no idea, my curiousity is more how much could it be to fix a broken repeater? I know it depends what is actually wrong but what could the max cost be?

It had been mangled by some outside watchmaker

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : May 25th, 2018-11:50
So, it could be quite a lot to repair that. Much more than just repairing the original issue.

would be amazed if service only cost 10k...

 
 By: gengar : May 25th, 2018-13:02
The piece in question (036-RM) appears to have been (improperly) serviced by a third-party watchmaker. To put it in perspective, an older but actually functioning Répétition Souveraine just sold at Antiquorum for CHF 125k earlier this month. So that is a ...