amanico
[JLC Moderator]
340308
The good news is that you cannot go wrong. My personal take would be the GMT. Because you can swim with it and you have a friendly complication. Now, the 39 mm case of the " 58 " is top! [nt]
No message body
BlackBay 58 or GMT?
I can have both, but have to choose.... This saturday. Would love to hear your advise, which i honour a lot! Thank You in advance Alberti
I would choose the 58
but only because I have a small wrist so a 39mm watch suits me better. I also like the fact that the 58 has a shorter height than all the other Black Bay models.
Hard arguments.... 😁
I like the size of the 58 much more. The GMT has a "contemporary" size. Not bad at all, but youre right, the 58 has a better size. Totally agree. Thank you
I dont have it yet, but have to choose, this saturday...
58 or gmt... looks like 58 is winning so far
GMT is a bit thick and big. I much prefer the new ceramic Pepsi Rolex.
The proportions of 58 are great. Best, Kari
I have the 58 and my son has the GMT.
Both great watches but a big difference in size and weight. No help I’m afraid but you can’t go wrong with either. Good luck. Regards Kev.
Thanks.
This is how it looks on my wrist. Acceptable. But i want it on a bracelet, if i go for the gmt... ...
Both great watches but i would pick the BB58
Had the GMT a while ago and i pref the smaller BB
Got it. Arent both watches 200m waterproof?
Yes, is the slimness of the case and tha design of the 58...
58, without a doubt.
Unless you have a big wrist and the 58 is too small for you, then I would doubt. Vte
I'm a wee bit biased
as i have the GMT,but it sits pretty comfortably on my small wrist,and the ' thickness ' doesn't really bother me. I had a chance to acquire the 58 subsequently,which i liked, but somehow decided to give it pass. The more i wear the GMT, the more i enjoy ...
Thanks Henry
I like the gmt, but never had the chance to try the 58... i think it really comes to the moment where i will see both and be able to try.. i like slimmer watches and do not really get the trend of bulky watches. What is going to be difficult is the gmt co...
I choose the 58
Both are very handsome in person, but the case thickness of the BB GMT is too high - looks unrefined imho. The 58 is well proportioned from pretty much any viewing angle.
Both are....
beautiful but I think that the gmt is a tad too thick... The 58 will prove to be mor3 comfortable Good luck Cheers
58 for me!
I have the 58 - the proportions is spot on and classic vintage look and feel. If you prefer a bigger, thicker sportier watch, go for GMT.
