foversta
[PuristSPro Moderator]
20814
Good question.
Can anyone clarify why the Lange is thought to be more robust?
I don't have services figures and I'm not able to tell you that % of the FPJ or of the Lange watches need to be serviced.
But what I can tell you is that Journe has an objective in his collection: to propose, whatever are the complications, always the same caliber thickness. It is a beautiful horological objective. Trouble is that it leads to a lot of constraints and increases the difficulty to create a reliable caliber.
About Lange, Lange is the only brand which assembles its calibers twice at the Manufacture to improve the reliability of the watches.
But again, both FPJ CS and Lange Saxonia AC are reliable watches.
Fr.Xavier
Available on the marketplace
FPJ Chronometre Souverain versus Lange Saxonia Annual Calendar
This is a hypothetical this or that since I have only seen the Saxonia Annual Calendar in photos at this point. I am attracted to the Lange's legibility for an annual calendar, combined with the moonphase and big date complications. In comparison, I am ve...
My take..
To me both look elegant and classy. I would prefer the annual calendar because of 1 simple reason. It's a clean symmetrical dial. It also has a moonphase to boost which is a plus.
lange calendar would be my choice
Lange all the way. and this may be controversial, but owning 3 lange's and one journe, i believe the langes are better made and more reliable. i've had almost zero mechanical problems with the langes other than doing stupid things like dropping them. and ...
Can you tell us why your FPJ doesn't get much wrist time?
Personally, I find the Lange not very stylish (not to say ugly) and the FPJ much more elegant atthough without power indicator it would be even more elegant.
Imo and to a degree this not an equal comparison...........
Because you are comparing a manual wind watch with only the one complication i.e. PR. Against an automatic piece with several complications. A fairer comparison may have been against the FP Journe Calendrier. May I ask is it because you are trying to deci...
Too different to compare them...
automatic vs handwind, not the same complication, not the same style... not the same price ! The CS is a beautiful watch from FPJ but I would tend to compare it to a Lange 1 more than to the Saxonia Annual Calendar. I like the balanced dial of the Saxonia...
When we talk about the looks,
so just the physical appearance of the watch; the FPJ wins IMHO. Next to each other, the Lange looks a bit boring. In general the FPJ is much more elegant end special. GEO
Appreciate the responses .....
I realize it's an odd comparison, but I think that is more true in life than not. I also didn't wanted to gather various points of view before saying too much. Why don't I wear the FPJ CS more often? - In part because of the more casual summer months comb...
Good question.
Can anyone clarify why the Lange is thought to be more robust? I don't have services figures and I'm not able to tell you that % of the FPJ or of the Lange watches need to be serviced. But what I can tell you is that Journe has an objective in his collect...
Xavier, good answer, but...................
Like Mac, I too now only wear my Journe at weekends and for special occasions. Were before it was my daily wearer for nearly a year, since my mishap (which was partially my fault) I now am very cautious when I am wearing it, just in case I catch or knock ...
fpj all the way
They are very different and therefore hard to compare, but the FPJ is just stunning. I'm biased as it's my grail watch, but the FPJ CS is the one of the most beautiful watches I have ever had the pleasure of wearing. I like Lange (particularly the datogra...
lange
i will leave the looks and asthetics to you, personally i like the Lange look more. beyond tht, your question raises "robustness" as a consideration. while i have no idea wht QC FPJ has, but i think not many will disagree Lange prob score higher on tht fr...
