Pop Quiz

Jan 28, 2021,08:54 AM
 

You have both of these watches in your hands and ask 50 strangers which one they would guess sells for $100,000...

Where are you placing your bets???



I like it. Don’t necessarily love it knowing I could have a Haldimann, MB


More posts: Haldimann

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

AdG newest take on 5711...

 
 By: redcorals : January 28th, 2021-07:42
...took 3yrs to make/ruin it depending on what you feel...lolz ...  

I would say kudos for the effort and audacity

 
 By: Mr.Gatsby : January 28th, 2021-07:46
But the honest truth is, an icon/legend needs no reintroduction or modification. Any alteration would have to come from the company (PP) itself to make sense.

In general I agree with this

 
 By: Brandon Skinner : January 28th, 2021-11:40
I feel the 5711 is just another watch, its not really rare or anything truly special. I personally know over 20 people who have had or currently own this watch. If the owner of it wants to spice it up, than more power to them. The real question is why? Wo... 

Ruin

 
 By: agyzace : January 28th, 2021-07:55

Love it

 
 By: agyzace : January 28th, 2021-07:57

;-))

 
 By: FabR : January 28th, 2021-07:59

I’m a fan of AdG

 
 By: Time to watch : January 28th, 2021-08:12
But not of this project, to put it plainly. H.

I’ve seen some spectacular modifications by Artisans De Geneve, where their work enhances a particular piece.

 
 By: BigAppleBill : January 28th, 2021-08:21
But with this one, “a solution in search of a problem” comes to mind.

I like it

 
 By: MiguelFlash : January 28th, 2021-08:30

Just because you can, doesn't mean you should...

 
 By: mdg : January 28th, 2021-08:34
...and the uncentered main spring near 12 is very disconcerting. There is an art to asymmetry and this ain't it : )

I recall a similar line from Jurassic Park...

 
 By: MichaelC : January 28th, 2021-09:32
And I fully agree with you.

Now Patek knows how

 
 By: piccolochimico (aka dsgalaxy1) : January 28th, 2021-08:52
Not to design a skeleton nautilus 😅🤡

Pop Quiz

 
 By: Brandon Skinner : January 28th, 2021-08:54
You have both of these watches in your hands and ask 50 strangers which one they would guess sells for $100,000... Where are you placing your bets??? I like it. Don’t necessarily love it knowing I could have a Haldimann, MB ...  

Hot Mess!

 
 By: Kurt Behm : January 28th, 2021-10:38
Awful. KPB

Monstrosity.

 
 By: CGJ0 : January 28th, 2021-12:36

Once I got past the dissonance..

 
 By: toxly347 : January 28th, 2021-12:38
.. it looks cool by itself. Just a watch.

Totally agree V 😉👍

 
 By: holdemchamp1225 : January 28th, 2021-14:22

For all the negative reactions, it is ultimately up the owner to do what he/she wants with their possession.

 
 By: Tim Jackson : January 28th, 2021-16:08
I like the skeltonization of the caliber, front and back, but I despise the carbon fiber bezel. Had AdG kept the orig bezel, I believe it would be a more coherent and in my opinion better looking final product. So for me, it misses the mark despite much o... 

Looking at the macros on their website, the finishing looks quite nice, better than what you'd get from Patek.

 
 By: jleno : January 28th, 2021-17:56
I'm all for it! I do agree that this would be better with the original bezel though.

I'm not a huge fan...

 
 By: patrick_y : February 4th, 2021-20:07
But who cares what I think? I'm just another person with another opinion. As long as the owner of this watch likes this watch, that's all that matters!

I Like It...

 
 By: elliot55 : February 6th, 2021-13:01
... I like it a lot. - Scott

Tells Me...

 
 By: elliot55 : February 6th, 2021-18:46
... No one really cares about the date.