need a real and honest contest

Nov 11, 2022,09:32 AM
 

To start, 80% of the bards don't even participate. That's already a reason why it's totally meaningless 

Then, you have to pay to enter the competition
And concerning the winners... Well we always have the same brands that will get a price, no matter what

It's a joke

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

GPHG 2022 Prize List

 
 By: patrick_y : November 11th, 2022-00:19
Here are the winners of the GPHG 2022! Big congrats to the winners! And below, we have a photo of the winner of the GPHG from last year! What are your thoughts? Are you pleased with the results? ...  

I am pleased

 
 By: sham1 : November 11th, 2022-03:19
that the Hermes and Trilobe won as they are on my hit list

Ahh!

 
 By: patrick_y : November 12th, 2022-03:32
I've yet to meet the Hermes, there's some unusual difficulty in setting the mechanism I'm told. And a previous Hermes watch, the double moon phase one, was also super counterintuitive to set. The Trilobe is a watch I've met and I've interviewed the founde... 

Thanks Patrick on the lowdown on the Hermes

 
 By: sham1 : November 12th, 2022-04:35
As you know I love simple watches so perhaps the Hermes is better to look at than to use. A 38.5mm Trilobe is crying out to me

Definitely a very cool timepiece!

 
 By: patrick_y : November 12th, 2022-11:52
That Trilobe is a very cool watch. Definitely like the watch, design, et. al. I even like the founder, whom I interviewed a year ago in November 2021. Swell guy.

Thanks Patrick for the endorsement!

 
 By: sham1 : November 13th, 2022-06:59
Sounds like my next watch!

Indeed!

 
 By: patrick_y : November 13th, 2022-09:47

I thought they were interesting...

 
 By: patrick_y : November 12th, 2022-03:33
Do you know exactly how some of these work? The MB&F Chronograph with its inverter set up is truly unique, a significant invention, and has a practical use case scenario. The Bird Automaton clock and the Miki Eleta Clock didn't catch your eye?

+1

 
 By: penfriend : November 11th, 2022-09:40

You have a point there.

 
 By: patrick_y : November 12th, 2022-03:33

need a real and honest contest

 
 By: Bruno.M1 : November 11th, 2022-09:32
To start, 80% of the bards don't even participate. That's already a reason why it's totally meaningless Then, you have to pay to enter the competition And concerning the winners... Well we always have the same brands that will get a price, no matter what ... 

Yes, definitely!

 
 By: amanico : November 12th, 2022-08:47

EISA Awards are the same, it is pay-to-play.

 
 By: enjoythemusic : November 11th, 2022-10:52
While we can debate their pay-for-play scheme, it is a fact for various industry 'Awards'. With the EISA, as i understand it, you pay to enter, and if you 'win', you also have to pay once again to license the use of their logo.

Overall, the GPHG isn't making money...

 
 By: patrick_y : November 12th, 2022-03:44
The GPHG isn't really making money. There isn't anyone getting a tremendous salary. And the amount paid by the nominees is pretty small. About CHF SFR 500 per entrant. Which doesn't even cover the cost to put on the event. Not to mention the admin costs a... 

Excellent Point, Many Thx For Posting

 
 By: enjoythemusic : November 12th, 2022-11:41
It helps the GPHG to offset the basic costs and am 100% cool with that. i'm a fan of their Awards, though do also understand the pros and cons of this method of Award organization. Perhaps at some point, another entity will bring forth a more comprehensiv...  

Nice watch!

 
 By: patrick_y : November 12th, 2022-11:51
I haven't been enjoying my "Turtle" very much. Need to go dig it out and start enjoying it more!

That Van Cleef and Arples Fountain and Bird is breathtaking.

 
 By: hoseachandra : November 11th, 2022-11:35
As for the rest, nothing particularly interesting. The Tag Heur Monaco Gulf and Tudor pelagos FXD...what is so special about them, i don't understand .

Agreed! The Automaton is breathtaking!

 
 By: patrick_y : November 12th, 2022-03:34
The other clock, the Miki Eleta clock is also breathtaking.

It was a good Awards show.

 
 By: enjoythemusic : November 11th, 2022-11:38
Sure we can debate a few things, yet overall imho they got it right. These award ceremonies are a way for an industry to thank themselves for their incredible efforts.

I agree. I feel really strongly about the Miki Eleta clock.

 
 By: patrick_y : November 12th, 2022-03:41
I would say they got it mostly right this year too! Not sure about the Hermes WorldTime for the Ladies' Complication Prize - I preferred the Van Cleef & Arpels flower petal opening and closing watch (12 flowers with petals that open, the number of open pe...