Funny, I had the Marine also in mind! 😃👍

Nov 11, 2022,11:00 AM
 

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Hypothetical Question: One Watch “Collection”

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-10:14
Hello Everyone, hope all is fine. Here’s a question: If you could only have one watch to keep, what would it be? It doesn’t have to be a watch in your collection currently. Aspirations are more than welcome as they drive the hobby. I pondered hard and sur...  

This guy

 
 By: andrea~ : November 11th, 2022-10:40
The datejust has always been my favorite watch and the one I feel emotionally attached to the most ...  

Excellent and Excellence

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-10:46
I can definitely feel it can be an only watch. And a very regal daily watch it is. Nice!

Thank you!

 
 By: andrea~ : November 11th, 2022-10:50
It does the job of an everyday watch really well

It’s not the favourite watch in my collection but the most versatile.

 
 By: Uncle Chico : November 11th, 2022-12:50
It can be worn in all seasons and for all occasions depending on the choice of strap or bracelet. Running a close second would be a JLC Reverso. ...  

You want me to die? The impossible answer to a cruel question...

 
 By: amanico : November 11th, 2022-10:47
Ok, if I had two guns on my head, and that I was forced to choose... Then... I would choose the guns. ))) More seriously, I think this one: There is something very romantic to end with the watch which started all, in my love for watches... ...  

I thought u would pick that

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-11:17
Excellent choice. They don’t make them like this anymore. So elegant, and charming.

I've thought about this before

 
 By: Arronax : November 11th, 2022-10:50
For me it would have to be a dive watch, not only for water resistance but also for lume and the bezel as a 60min timer and to take daily abuse. In the current state of my collection it would be a hard choice between my pam25 or my searambler.

PAM25 is..

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-11:18
The beauty and the Beast at the same time. It is an excellent choice my friend.

Easily and without question this...

 
 By: BigFatPauli : November 11th, 2022-10:59
I can dress it up or down, it looks good on a leather, rubber or bracelet. It is water resistant enough. There really just isn't something it can't do! I've had mine since 2003 or 2004 and it is still, by far, my most worn watch.I absolutely love it. ...  

100%, super!

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-11:16
This one steals my heart too. I believe, it could be my only watch too. Wonderful!

The more I look at it, the more I think that my Breguet would be a one watch collection.

 
 By: COUNT DE MONET : November 11th, 2022-10:59
A single collection piece would have to be able to show others that you are a watch collector, a watch lover. My Breguet would be such a watch. ...  

Very intellectual and mezmerising

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-11:20
Love it. I had the privilege to handle this piece only once at the AD. It costed a bomb but I couldn’t put it down. It is the most Breguet of Breguets in my mind.

Yes I see what you said

 
 By: ChristianDK : December 12th, 2022-22:21
Very well put.

For me it would be a patek 3940

 
 By: @lberti : November 11th, 2022-11:00
Credit WBLDN ...  

So complicated yet so simple

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-11:21
It is hard to fit both criteria in and succeed. This is the superlative.

Voila 🙏

 
 By: @lberti : November 11th, 2022-11:27

Good choice, good choice...

 
 By: amanico : November 11th, 2022-11:36

😂😉

 
 By: FabR : November 11th, 2022-12:31

Only a man with such wealth

 
 By: Arronax : November 11th, 2022-11:57
Could have a whole town made to match the dial on his watch? Or was that the other way around

🤣🤣😁👍

 
 By: TeutonicCarFan : November 11th, 2022-13:43

;-))

 
 By: FabR : November 11th, 2022-16:30

You really want to torture us my friend! But what is your answer for you?

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : November 11th, 2022-11:34
But if I must keep only one this one: ...  

Excellent choice

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-12:46
If I have that, it could also be an only watch piece. I will be contented and smile whenever I look at it.

It's a great reference from the crown! Cheers!

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : November 11th, 2022-18:39

The lume is awesome.

 
 By: amanico : November 11th, 2022-16:20

Excellent choice

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-12:46
Good question. I think, for me, a rose gold Seamaster trilogy piece, if it exists. Or a SM300 heritage in gold, with a black dial, if it exists, with a rubber strap. Ooo that will be my end-all piece. This piece I got recently kinda fits the spec too. If ...  

Nice choice!

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : November 11th, 2022-18:38

Beautiful

 
 By: TeutonicCarFan : November 11th, 2022-13:28
Definitely says a lot since this is a new one as well!

Wow!

 
 By: diracpoint : November 11th, 2022-14:24
That looks AWESOME on the green strap!😍

Thanks...green suits it well indeed

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : November 11th, 2022-18:42

That’s true deep love my dear Yacomino!! Wow!!

 
 By: Subexplorer : November 12th, 2022-04:04
You are deeply in love with this one! And I can easily understand you. I’m happy to know you love it so much!! Cheers! Abel

Indeed the love for the CDV is very strong! There is just something about it that when I put it on, it just feels like … me! I mean a perfect fit at every level.

 
 By: Chronometer (aka yacomino) : November 12th, 2022-12:19
It also gave me the desire to own more Vacheron as I am really loving my traditionnelle as well! Cheers my friend

I can well understand your feelings dear Yacomino. Of course we…

 
 By: Subexplorer : November 12th, 2022-16:30
… always love the watches we buy but some watches inspires us a deeper connection. It’s like a magic we discover in some watches which make them very special to us. The CdV is one of those timepieces no doubt. Keep enjoying it so much and let’s see which ... 

Rolex is on a roll

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-12:48
Indeed, perfect one watch. I miss my old kermit. It’s traded away and it could have been my only piece. Oddly, I just thought of an analogy. A good wife/girlfriend is only appreciated when they are gone, and one looks back to realize how good they were. W... 

A Rolex Submariner 5508 NOS!

 
 By: Mary Anny : November 11th, 2022-12:36
And no access to the Internet for many years!

Well said!

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-12:49

Like that?

 
 By: amanico : November 11th, 2022-15:29
...  

Exactly!

 
 By: Mary Anny : November 11th, 2022-15:36

;)

 
 By: amanico : November 11th, 2022-17:38

Bad, bad question

 
 By: JLCman : November 12th, 2022-11:16
For me no Rolex, no Omega, even no Patek or VC. Just my Grand Seiko Snowflake. What a luck that I must not decide for a one-watch-collection ;-))

Too many Rolexes!

 
 By: K-Lo : November 11th, 2022-12:37
Here is mine! ...  

Excellent choice Ted

 
 By: Cookies : November 11th, 2022-12:49
Gold is beautiful, rare and regal. I love Gold.

Awesome! Stay well my good Sire!

 
 By: K-Lo : November 11th, 2022-12:51
Love your post!!

It’s not easy to answer such a question.

 
 By: ChristianDK : November 11th, 2022-13:14
What would be the criteria for making the decision? The watch I love the most? My grail? …but does it have to be practical for most situations? Versatile? Robust? These criteria can bring conflicting answers. A compromise between these criteria may also n...  

Wow this is a wonder

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-19:24
I love FPJ. Handled a few and it was a privilege to do so. Wow!

The polar is the classic

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-19:23
So nice

I can easily see going with a watch that can do it all..

 
 By: Echi : November 11th, 2022-13:39
But then the options will tend to be too practical such that the choice becomes an appliance more than a source of joy. In my mind, I initially blurted out Sub! But then I say to myself, that would be like giving up on life, ain’t it? So I go for the watc...  

Ooo the red reverso

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-19:23
The one that got away…I admire this piece

my beloved PP 5960P

 
 By: patrickh : November 11th, 2022-13:58
without any doubt. ...  

Why not, indeed.

 
 By: amanico : November 11th, 2022-15:20

Elegant and sporty

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-19:22
I must go see this piece in real life.

Allow a second watch and it will be thousand times easier ...

 
 By: als1678 : November 11th, 2022-14:32
How does one find one piece which is beautiful, versatile, classic? No wonder so many chose Rolex! For me it will be a watch that I don't yet own, probably not even in by top 5 of the wish list given my current collection. But if we are talking about one ...  

Crazy!

 
 By: amanico : November 11th, 2022-15:22

I saw this on a watch display window

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-19:21
So nice and the price is astronomical. The curvature is a hidden detail. Love it!

5970, white or rose gold.

 
 By: massi. : November 11th, 2022-15:14

One watch

 
 By: GuyT : November 11th, 2022-15:16
Richard Mille RM009 - only seen pictures and read articles and doubt that I will ever see one but love the look.

Rakish choice

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-19:20
RMs are so avante garde

This!

 
 By: jml_watches : November 11th, 2022-15:47
Hi I know lots of people are going for robust divers or similar, but thought I'd take a different approach. Might not be the most robust or the most versatile, but would give me lots of pleasure. I'd have to go for my grail watch Photo credit Art. ( Thank...  

A Reverso is a great choice

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-19:20
And this piece is a masterpiece I see

That is nearly impossible to answer. But if i am forced to have only one...

 
 By: hoseachandra : November 11th, 2022-15:50
It should come with bracelet, screw down crown and caseback, has date (just in case i need it), good legibility, and comfortable (not to thick or wide). And has lume even if it minimal. So this one (or if IWC are not stupid , the new incoming Ingenieur) :...  

Excellent choice

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-12:40
It is a joy

Patek 89. I know it's beyond (Pie In The Sky...)

 
 By: Kurt Behm : November 11th, 2022-16:01
But I would gladly have all of my trouser pockets altered to carry this treasure. I'd also need two bodyguards to make sure it stayed on watch would cause me to give up wristwatches forever. Oh well, at least I can dream. Great weekends Kurt ...  

Is that the Grave’s piece

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-06:31
Rumour had it H.Graves found it to be a bad luck charm. Something about a drowning incident.

I don’t believe so…

 
 By: Kurt Behm : November 16th, 2022-03:35
The Patek 89 was introduced in the 1990’s.

Wish I had the chance to get that

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-06:29
I never got the call=c

Cool choice!

 
 By: amanico : November 11th, 2022-17:39

Thanks. 🥰

 
 By: Pun : November 11th, 2022-18:18

I owned the 5020...

 
 By: Kurt Behm : November 11th, 2022-17:46
in rose gold and traded it to Paul Duggan for a double split. I should have kept the Patek but hindsight is always 20/20. Kurt

Amen.

 
 By: Kurt Behm : November 11th, 2022-20:35

🎩 Thank you sir!

 
 By: Pun : November 12th, 2022-05:11
Regards

My pleasure👍🥂

 
 By: FabR : November 12th, 2022-17:30

Nice shape!

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-06:29

Only one from my collection? . . .

 
 By: Dr No : November 11th, 2022-18:06
. . . Black Connie. Impractical, but then, neither is true love. 😌 From all the watches in the world? Maybe this: PP ref 3939. Tourbillon. Steel, one of one. 33.3 mm. I even had it on my wrist once. ...  

I felt this one was coming dear Art!! A sublime Omega!!

 
 By: Subexplorer : November 12th, 2022-04:07
Great choice!! Cheers my dear friend! Abel

Black Connie is beautiful

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-06:28
And that Patek “tourbillon on the rear” is sublime.

That particular Patek would be even more impractical than Black Connie . . .

 
 By: Dr No : November 12th, 2022-20:27
. . . because it would probably spend almost as much time in their service department as on my wrist, but oh, what enjoyment it would bring!

The Datograph Perpetual on the bracelet

 
 By: donizetti : November 11th, 2022-21:35
would keep me happy I think. Best Andreas ...  

Complex yet simple

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-06:27
Love it!

As of now mine would be the GO PML with the ruthenium dial. I'll explain why below, but can I just take this moment to say that a "one watch collection" makes as much sense as "a herd of cow"? :)

 
 By: Rosneathian : November 11th, 2022-23:50
Here are the reasons for my choice: 1. It's a very good mid-tier watch with not much like it at around its retail price 2. It's a shadow of a watch. The colours of this iteration make it difficult to notice, even when it peeks out from under a sleeve 4. I...  

Nice stealthy dial

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-06:26
I like grey the most

Hello dear Cookies! I thought I wouldn’t be able to answer …

 
 By: Subexplorer : November 12th, 2022-04:00
… your question. Just one watch? May be a twelve watches collection? What about a six watches collection? Just one? Only one? After much thinking I arrived to the answer: my first “serious” watch. My first Rolex. My only watch through many many years befo...  

Oooo perfection is in it

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-06:25
A 2-liner. Nice patina on it. A perfect only watch!

Go big or go home, right?!

 
 By: Brandon Skinner : November 12th, 2022-04:51
...  

Indeed

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-08:47
This is the marvel.

This will be quite impossible.

 
 By: S F : November 12th, 2022-06:00
In that situation, I will just give it all up and be done with it altogether 😂 If it is a condition that i must keep one watch then it will be the evergreen 1675 GMTM gilt. ...  

Perfection!

 
 By: Cookies : November 12th, 2022-06:26
It can also be my only watch. Perfect!

I am with you on that choice!

 
 By: amanico : November 12th, 2022-08:29

Rolex ref. 1018.

 
 By: mkvc : November 12th, 2022-07:05
For me it must be waterproof, extremely versatile, lightweight and unostentatious. Ironically, I have two 1018s and I don't wear them frequently because most of the time I don't need a waterproof watch and when I need a waterproof watch I tend to wear som... 

One stealthy piece it is

 
 By: Cookies : November 14th, 2022-17:42
Love the bracelet and curves on it. Great choice!

Thanks, wears nicely…

 
 By: Andy_Mac : November 14th, 2022-18:10
…and feels like a quality, well made piece. I like it!

Any George Daniels wristwatch. Not because of the obvious value or exclusivity, but because of the workmanship.

 
 By: Emil Wojcik : December 12th, 2022-22:28
His watches are mesmerizing to me, even if they lack the incredible finishing of other makers. It's the thought of the man's process--picturing him sitting at his bench filing a gear or making a tiny screw--that's where the value is for me. Of the watches...  

Thanks!

 
 By: Emil Wojcik : December 12th, 2022-23:04

Excellence there

 
 By: Cookies : December 13th, 2022-12:38
I respect that watch. It is solid and well made

This is such a tough question.

 
 By: singingbee : December 13th, 2022-10:27
If possible, I would love to have a two watches collection instead. And they will be these two. If it is compulsory that I can only keep one, it will be the Daytona as I think as an overall package, it will be a perfect one watch collection. ...  

Complementary. Good choices.

 
 By: amanico : December 13th, 2022-10:39

Stunning choices

 
 By: Cookies : December 13th, 2022-12:39
I like the Lange. It looks great on you. The Daytona I respect. It is a very elegant chronograph. The thin-ness is spot on.