Full agree Monsieur Fancy Pants :-)

Oct 21, 2021,20:45 PM
 

Can’t beat what you’ve said. Makes hell a lotta sense.
BR
GatSby

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

What are your opinion on homage watches?

 
 By: kevinc1001 : October 21st, 2021-00:25
In the more affordable forums homages are seen as two of the following 1) A good alternative to expensive watches or 2) Ripoffs of the actual thing. Now opinions are subjective I’m one of those people who look at homage as the alternative just as long as ... 

I happen to agree with #1 and...

 
 By: India Whiskey Charlie : October 21st, 2021-01:10
As long as a watch doesn't pretend to be a certain brand it isn't (a fake), I am okay with that. ...  

I've made my peace with the Patek 5522A

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : October 21st, 2021-02:25
😼

Oh

 
 By: kevinc1001 : October 21st, 2021-05:18
I would show my Patek 5711 homage but now I’m afraid too lol

+1, Salman.

 
 By: amanico : October 21st, 2021-06:15

...

 
 By: PalmSprings : October 21st, 2021-08:52
What do you think of the 'new' Tornek Rayville? I understand where the people behind that company are coming from. Companies like Blancpain are missing out and you can bring up ''do not repeat the past'' like someone at Ferrari once said (at least I think... 

You make good points...

 
 By: India Whiskey Charlie : October 21st, 2021-15:34
Tornek-Rayville is a good example of an homage which might be more acceptable because it's based on a vintage watch model rather than a watch made to look like a current generation watch. The Gevril Tribeca is another example of an homage based of a vinta... 

Tornek-Rayville

 
 By: India Whiskey Charlie : October 21st, 2021-20:22
...  

I guess the line between "homage" and "ripoff" can be very blurred, one that's in fact (intentionally) hard to define...in general, I'm totally against homages if these typically concern "imitations," with no novel design or horological contribution.

 
 By: FabR : October 21st, 2021-03:07
As a friendly remark, the argument in favor of choosing a homage because we can't afford the real model is dangerously close to the argument we hear for fakes, and on many levels, it might be nearly as difficult to justify....my personal code of conduct i... 

😸

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : October 21st, 2021-13:29

;-)

 
 By: FabR : October 21st, 2021-15:23

Full agree Monsieur Fancy Pants :-)

 
 By: Mr.Gatsby : October 21st, 2021-20:45
Can’t beat what you’ve said. Makes hell a lotta sense. BR GatSby

Glorified fakes

 
 By: artconcept00746 : October 22nd, 2021-11:25
Just buy a seiko and be proud of it, homage watches are never the answer.

Sorry but I have to disagree

 
 By: kevinc1001 : October 22nd, 2021-15:46
I would if the watch in question had the name of said manufacturer on it but if it’s any other name I don’t see a problem.