WatchProSite Forum Ethics & Comportment

Key Points from the Discussion

• The community finds the 'pump and dump' practice repugnant, where a watch is posted in a discussion forum and then quickly listed for sale in the Collectors Market. While exceptions exist, it's considered a breach of decorum to leverage forum visibility for commercial gain.
• The forum's value lies in its genuine discussions, respect, and humor, largely free from covert marketing or commercial input, which is a key reason for its appreciation among members.
• A contributor questions the 'pump and dump' concept, seeking clarification on how posting a watch for discussion before selling it truly constitutes unethical pumping or dumping, beyond simply adhering to the policy.
• The Collectors Market is primarily intended for members to thin out overgrown collections or move on watches they no longer desire, rather than serving as a primary income source for professional sellers.
• While some rules may seem obvious, a clear and explicit reminder is beneficial for all members to ensure understanding and adherence to community standards.
• A two-day separation between posting a watch in a discussion forum and then listing it in the Collectors Market is considered contrary to the spirit of the site, even if it's an unwritten rule.