
Nicetomeetyou's initial impressions of the Tudor Pelagos 39 sparked a vibrant discussion among collectors, delving into its design choices, material properties, and market positioning. This article synthesizes the community's immediate reactions to the new release, offering a comprehensive look at what makes this downsized Pelagos a compelling, albeit debated, addition to Tudor's dive watch lineup. His observations on the watch's aesthetic nods to vintage Tudors and its potential competition with the Black Bay 58 set the stage for a deeper dive into its horological significance.

... the rehaut will be missed and I prefer the design of the BB58 overall.
I'm a little perturbed that Tudor did not release a blue version at the same time. We all know it's coming but I'm annoyed by this type of slow play releases. As for the watch itself, I do wish the date remained as the North Flag at 40mm could still squeeze in a date and power reserve. However, I suppose to get higher WR, the movement had to be smaller. The loss of the HEV is of no consequence to 99.99% of buyers.
Maybe a date version is also possible down the line
Personally I prefer the stainless steel blue BB58
Will be interesting to see them side to side. Iām sure that we will soon see video/photo comparisons online.
I think the rose makes more sense on the old Tudor sub. And the shield with the snowflake. Credit unknown Credit unknown
This thread is active on the Rolex forum with 58 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.
Join the Discussion →