Tourbillon Size Comparison: Small vs. Large

Bruno.M1 · 2021-10-30T08:18:02Z

Explore the debate on tourbillon size in luxury watches. Collectors discuss aesthetic preferences, technical implications, and the visual impact of large vs. small tourbillons.

Bruno.M1's thought-provoking question about tourbillon size invites collectors to consider the aesthetic impact of this complex mechanism. By asking readers to disregard brand and other complications, Bruno.M1 focuses the discussion purely on the visual preference for a large versus small tourbillon, a detail often overshadowed by broader watch design. This article synthesizes community insights, exploring both technical and artistic perspectives on tourbillon presentation.

2 examples but DON'T look at the brand, case, dial, other complications. PLEASE ONLY THE TOURBILLON

My question is ' do you like a small or big tourbillon? ' and sharing WHY would be interesting

For me itss BIG without doubt. To me it just looks much more appealing

But I have no idea if there are positive or negative technical reasons to prefer one to the other

Key Points from the Discussion

While tourbillons are often seen as a technical marvel, some horological experts, like Philippe Dufour, consider them 'silly and pointless' in terms of practical timekeeping benefit, viewing them more as a form of art.
The aesthetic appeal of a tourbillon is not solely about its size but also its overall integration within the watch's design, including its structure and precise placement on the dial.
A larger tourbillon can present a dilemma for collectors who prefer smaller watch cases, as a prominent tourbillon often necessitates a larger overall watch size.
Many collectors appreciate the tourbillon more for its visual spectacle and technical artistry rather than its functional contribution to timekeeping accuracy, suggesting that if it's present, it should be visually impactful.
For those new to collecting tourbillons, starting with a more accessible movement, such as an Asian-made one, can be a way to experience the complication before investing in higher-end pieces.

The Discussion

amanico

Oct 30, 2021

Well, the other side of this Reverso Tribute Tourbillon is more appealing, me think:

Bur here, from your pictures, I would go for the big. Best, Nicolas

DouglasM

Nov 1, 2021

wow, that's beautiful

amanico

Nov 1, 2021

Yes, this side is really great looking.

CGJ0

Nov 4, 2021

I nearly told you off for not answering the question ;) Saved yourself with the last sentence!

kjkt3

Oct 30, 2021

All wonderful and ridiculous at the same time. Few objects are more useless to humanity than a high-end wristwatch with a tourbillon.

FabR

Oct 30, 2021

Most high-end watches *without* a tourbillon would seem an equally good example in this respect..😂😉

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Horological Meandering forum with 28 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →