Swatch Sistem51 Review: Machine-Made Marvel
Review

Swatch Sistem51 Review: Machine-Made Marvel

By TOPLIMIT · Dec 29, 2013 · 21 replies
TOPLIMIT
WPS member · Horological Meandering forum
21 replies7528 views7 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 ✉ 🔗

TOPLIMIT's review of the Swatch Sistem51 offers a timely look back at a watch that captured significant attention upon its 2013 release. This article explores the initial impressions and community reactions to Swatch's innovative, fully machine-assembled mechanical movement. Readers gain insight into the watch's unique appeal and perceived drawbacks from early adopters.

21 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →

Blame it on the internet, they say.

It all began when I was surfing the internet using the free Wifi at the Manor departmental store in Lucerne, Switzerland. It was dinner time, and free Wifi is hard to come by in Switzerland. So, while I was busying looking through Facebook, I happened to see a post by a renowned watch blogger, SJX. He mentioned that the Swatch Sistem51 is only available in Switzerland at the moment. And everything else, after that, is history.

It has been 2 weeks since I first had this watch, and I must say, it has been on my wrist for quite a number of days recently (and I am wearing it as I am writing this!). It is a simple, but fun watch. But what is the fuss all about with the Sistem51?

Launched in the 2013 Baselworld, the Swatch Sistem51 is considered a horological marvel; a piece of history in the making. It is the first mechanical watch that is fully assembled with machines, and its movement (which has 51 components) is held by only one screw. Intriguing.

Its stats are impressive too. 90 hour power reserve. Precision of +/- 10 seconds a day (It is not an expensive watch, so don’t expect COSC standards). Date indicator. “In-house” movement. All in a watch that cost CHF150. But lets ignore the geeky aspect of the watch, shall we?

What I like about this watch is that it is a really simple. Nothing fanciful. Nothing showy. It is a piece that you can just wear with a T-Shirt and Bermuda. It is really light too, since its casing is made in plastic. Yes, not many people will like a watch that is case in plastic, but it is nice to have something different once in a while, right? And while it may sound kiddish, the oscillating weight of the watch is kinda fun to play with, too! Furthermore, the clear caseback display adds a really neat touch to the watch as well.

There are several aspects of the watch, however, that I am not quite a fan of. Firstly, it is a little difficult to tell time. This is due to the slightly complex dial design that they have got there. While the design adds a nice touch to the watch, but I would prefer it to be slightly toned down.

The second and third problem lies in the picture above. The lugs, as seen in the picture, is a little unorthodox. And because of this, it would be difficult to change the watch strap to another one, since the design is different from the common strap designs that you’d see. Also, the movement is a tad too noisy for my liking. Yes, it is not an expensive watch, but I would have like it to be softer. Perhaps it is just me, but oh well.

I have not tested the accuracy of the watch, but I will do so within the next few days. Overall, this watch is something that I’d add into my collection, in the name of fun. While there are several aspects of the watch that I do not like, but I would cast it aside because frankly, this watch is just simply amazing. At this kind of price, and with its technological marvel, you would quickly forgive the “loudness” of the movement, or the confusing dial. It goes back to the fundamental reason of why I like watches- the creative and ingenious aspect of watchmaking. The movement and the watchmaking process itself is a horological marvel, and this is just the tip of the iceberg. Mark my words. This is the future of watchmaking.

(P.S. While I mentioned that this is the future of watchmaking, I still expect the marque brands to craft their watches using the traditional way, with the human touch. But this technology will pave way for more affordable mechanical watches, which will allow more people to join in the ranks of owning a piece of mechanical watch. And this is something that I definitely welcome.)

Pros:

- Lightweight (which, on the other hand, can be a con for others as well)

- Relatively cheap for a mechanical watch

- Long power reserve

Cons:

- Slight difficulty in reading the time with complex dial design

- Noisy movement

- Weird lug design


Picture time!






























Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
DO
DonCorson
Dec 30, 2013
Wow, you must have gotten the first one sold !

None of the stores around me in Switzerland have any. I have one on order, we will see how long it takes to arrive. Is this your first Swatch? If you have others I think you would recognise the lugs/strap and the loudness. All Swatches have lugs/straps like that and most are very loud. Have fun! Don

TO
TOPLIMIT
Dec 30, 2013
Nahhhh!

Really? I got mine in Lucerne. Yes, this is my first Swatch. Hahaha I think you misinterpreted the 'loudness' part. I meant that the movement was loud; the ticking sound that it makes can be audible in a relatively quiet environment! Best, Robin

DO
DonCorson
Dec 30, 2013
Yes that is what I did mean..

The first Swatches ticked very loud. At some point in time they made changes to make them quieter. Then they got complaints that they weren't real Swatches any more, too quiet. Now some models are loud, others quieter, but all louder than most watches. Don

AN
Andy
Dec 31, 2013
Yes Don they are loud aren't they....

I have a few but the last one I got which is the skeleton version is so loud I can't keep it in the bedroom as it would keep me awake.!! Can't wait to get one of these new ones and my local Swatch shop is now saying Feb. Yours, Andy.

CM
cmclee
Dec 30, 2013
thanks for sharing..

and a very well written review with very frank comments and opinions !

TO
TOPLIMIT
Dec 30, 2013
Thanks for taking the time to read my review

Appreciate your feedback. It is heartening to see my works being appreciated; it keeps me writing! Best, Robin

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Horological Meandering forum with 21 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →