Stepan Sarpaneva S.U.F Komentaja Review
Review

Stepan Sarpaneva S.U.F Komentaja Review

By WHL · May 27, 2008 · 8 replies
WHL
WPS member · Horological Meandering forum
8 replies3557 views8 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

WHL presents an insightful review of the Stepan Sarpaneva S.U.F Komentaja, a military-style watch from Stepan Sarpaneva's more accessible S.U.F line. This article explores Sarpaneva's motivation for creating this line—to fund his more avant-garde Sarpaneva-branded watches—and details the Komentaja's design, specifications, and movement. WHL provides a balanced perspective on this high-quality yet understated offering from an independent watchmaker.

8 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
Much has been said about the watches that bear the Sarpaneva signature. Stepan Sarpaneva’s bold designs such as the Supernova, Loiste, and Korona series of watches are all attention grabbers. Less well known is his S.U.F line. S.U.F stands for SarpanevaUhrenFabrik. The core model of this collection is the Komentaja, or Commander, which is one of many watches in the crowded and competitive marketplace for military-style watches.







Stepan started this line to give himself a sideline business that was separate from his Sarpaneva labeled watches, with the goal of making high quality but inexpensive watches to allow him to make watches under his own name rather than having to make watches for others to earn his living (In the past he has worked for Michael Parmigiani, Vianney Halter, and Christophe Claret). In order to keep it simple, he has outsourced everything but the assembly of these watches, which he does himself. It is obvious that the suppliers Stepan has chosen do high quality work. The case has a nice satin finish, the dial is cleanly printed on a matte black base, and the movement is attractively finished.

Stepan has offered other, limited edition watches under the S.U.F label.





Paroni





Palander





Ässä-discontinued


The Komentaja is a comfortable and fashionable 40 mm in diameter, excluding crown, and 9.7 high. The caseback is held down by five screws. The watch is water resistant to 10 atm. My watch comes on a Kevlar strap. Leather straps are also available. There is an alternative set of hands that the buyer could choose:







The buckle is different from any that I have come across before:







It took a day to get used to it, but I quite like the symmetry of it on the inside of my wrist.

There are some qualities the watch does not possess. The crown does not screw down. The date on the Soprod A-10 does not jump instantaneously at midnight, but rather slowly switches over to the next date after about 30 minutes. However, there is a quickset function for date correction should the watch not be worn for some time.

Stepan used to use the ETA 2824 inside his S.U.F watches. He switched to the Soprod A-10 last year due to concerns about ETA not supplying movements outside of the Swatch Group. Soprod made the A-10 as a  direct replacement for ETA 2892. The width dimensions are the same between the 2892, 2824, and A-10, so the same hands and dials one used for ETA movements can also be used for the A-10, but the A-10 is 1 mm thicker than the 2824, so casing modifications may be necessary. It has a 42 hour power reserve and hacking seconds. I cannot speak to its reliability yet, but I think that the A10 is a more attractive movement than the 2824. The movements are finished by Soprod. Stepan will adjust them if neccessary.













A note about the serial numbers: the top numbers engraved into the caseback - 23.50 on my watch - mean watch number 23 out of 50 total. The bottom number is the serial number of the watch. In my case, I have the 489th S.U.F produced, Komentaja and others too. There has been previous series of S.U.F Komentaja watches, with the ETA movement, and there is currently a run of 20 with a carbon fiber dial.

The watch comes in a nice Beco leather case and carries a two-year warrantee. It took less than a month between ordering the watch, with full payment due at the time of order, to delivery.

The S.U.F Komentaja is priced between IWC’s Mark XV on the high side and the Sinn 556 on the low. I find it to be a compelling value, and I am happy that in buying it I have supported a watchmaker whose vision I want to see furthered.


Bill

About the Sinn Ref. Sinn556

The Sinn 556 Emerald is a distinctive variant within the 556 series, known for its focus on legibility and robust construction in a versatile form factor. This particular model stands out due to its vibrant green dial, offering a unique aesthetic compared to the more common black or anthracite dials found across the standard 556 collection. It maintains the core design principles of the series, emphasizing functional clarity and understated tool-watch characteristics, while introducing a touch of color that appeals to collectors seeking a subtle yet impactful visual difference.

The watch features a stainless steel case, typically measuring 38.5mm in diameter, making it suitable for a wide range of wrist sizes. It is powered by a self-winding mechanical movement, often a modified ETA 2824-2 or Sellita SW200-1, providing reliable timekeeping with a power reserve of approximately 38 hours. The crystal protecting the dial is sapphire, known for its scratch resistance, and the watch is equipped with a display case back, allowing a view of the movement. Water resistance is rated to 200 meters, underscoring its practical durability.

This reference appeals to collectors who appreciate Sinn's engineering philosophy but desire a more expressive dial option than the traditional offerings. The Emerald variant adds a contemporary flair to the otherwise classic and utilitarian 556 lineup, making it a notable piece for those who value both performance and a distinctive appearance. Its balanced proportions and robust specifications ensure its relevance as an everyday watch, while the specific dial color provides a point of interest for enthusiasts.

Specifications

Caliber
ETA 2824-2 or Sellita SW200-1
Case
Stainless steel
Diameter
38.5mm
Dial
Green
Water Resist.
200m
Crystal
Sapphire

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement

Available on the marketplace

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Horological Meandering forum with 8 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →