Rolex Sky-Dweller vs. Patek Philippe Nautilus 5712/1A: Blue Dial Comparison

holdemchamp1225 · 2020-12-30T12:14:22Z

Explore a direct comparison of the Rolex Sky-Dweller and Patek Philippe Nautilus Ref. 5712/1A blue dials. See how sunburst and gradient finishes differ.

In this insightful comparison, WatchProSite's own holdemchamp1225 provides a direct, side-by-side look at two highly coveted blue dials: the Rolex Sky-Dweller and the Patek Philippe Nautilus Ref. 5712/1A. His original post highlights the critical nuances in dial finishes that often get lost in individual photos, emphasizing how different "blue" can truly be. This article synthesizes community reactions to his detailed visual analysis, offering diverse perspectives on these iconic timepieces.

Not all blue dials are equal or even similar. Look at the difference from the somewhat sunburst blue dial of the SkyD with the more gradient blue/grey dial of the 5712/1A.

The difficulty of comparing watches is to have them side by side and in similar lighting to be able to see the nuances as photos could be touched up, lack of color balance, white balance, saturation, etc...

Honestly, out of these 2, I prefer the SkyD blue dial in color. What do you guys think?

Key Points from the Discussion

The Patek Philippe Nautilus Ref. 5712/1A's horizontal 'slats' on its dial are a distinctive design element preferred by some collectors over the Rolex Sky-Dweller's sunburst finish.
The Rolex Sky-Dweller's blue dial is described as mesmerizing, with some collectors expressing a desire to add both the Sky-Dweller and the Patek Philippe Ref. 5712 to their collections, acknowledging the acquisition challenges for both references.
The discussion prompted a visual contribution from another member, showcasing a different blue dial, further illustrating the variety within the 'blue dial' category.

The Discussion

@lberti

Dec 30, 2020

I do like SKYD blue better. PP looks greenish. It would be interessting to see including Vacherons Overseas in blue.

holdemchamp1225

Dec 30, 2020

I don't own a VC OS 4500V blue dial but hope to add one in the future. I will make another post and comparison tomorrow with my FPJ Chronomètre Bleu which has an amazing dial and probably voted within the top 3 blue dials at the moment 👍

Chronometer (aka yacomino)

Dec 30, 2020

I do prefer the blue shade of the Rolex but I much prefer the Patek overall here...and to now contradict myself, I don’t think the blue of the Rolex would work on the patek...

So if I prefer the patek I guess I prefer it’s blue!

holdemchamp1225

Dec 30, 2020

I know it is an apples to oranges type of comparison as these 2 are not very similar in functionality, size, nor purpose but we can at least see the different hues of blue 😉

holdemchamp1225

Dec 30, 2020

Will do another post tomorrow 😉

holdemchamp1225

Dec 30, 2020

It will be fun what people think and choose after this one 😉

Rolex Sky-Dweller vs. Patek Philippe Nautilus 5712/1A: Blue Dial Comparison

Key Points from the Discussion

Continue the conversation