71 replies16775 views1 photos
Miranda's original post sparks a vital discussion within the WatchProSite community regarding the integrity of luxury watch journalism, particularly concerning new Rolex releases. Her direct challenge to the notion that disliking new models equates to being a 'dumbass' sets the stage for a broader examination of media trustworthiness and the independence of watch critics. This article synthesizes the community's diverse perspectives on navigating industry narratives.
Can we trust the press to be actually trustworthy? I will be Geneva tomorrow to report
Mine will be a little bit less bum licking
Key Points from the Discussion
- The community largely agrees that recent Rolex offerings, with exceptions like the yellow gold Le Mans Daytona and platinum 1908, have been uninspiring, suggesting a need for more critical reporting.
- A significant sentiment is that mainstream press often lacks objectivity, with some contributors suggesting that WatchProSite's well-educated global community offers a more reliable source of information.
- Some contributors express frustration with interviewers who dominate conversations, fawn over every release, and fail to ask challenging questions about innovation or design choices.
- Specific criticism is leveled at Rolex's recent lineup, with one member finding 'nothing... worth a second of my time' and noting the 'weird and un-Rolex-y' Deepsea branding changes.
- Beyond Rolex, other brands like JLC are perceived as trying too hard to join the 'holy trinity,' while Cartier and Chopard are highlighted for their more interesting releases.
- A contrasting view suggests that brands like Rolex and Patek Philippe thrive on continuity rather than radical mechanical or design innovation, making 'little (if none) wonders' at events like Watches & Wonders normal.
- One contributor notes a growing preference for Tudor's recent products over Rolex's, indicating a shift in collector interest towards brands offering more compelling new releases.
- The discussion also touches on the ethics of press engagement, with a moderator clarifying WatchProSite's policy on accepting event invitations, food, and logistical arrangements, but not gifts exceeding maximum value.
Advertisement
Continue the conversation
This thread is active on the Rolex forum with 71 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.
Join the Discussion →