Roger W. Smith Series 2: An Independent Watchmaking Icon

Key Points from the Discussion

• Roger W. Smith watches are considered a unique experience and a part of watch history, representing the pinnacle of independent watchmaking for many collectors.
• The ability of Roger W. Smith and a few other watchmakers to create nearly everything in-house and by hand is an achievement that supports craftsmanship and is akin to sponsoring the art form.
• While the technical mastery of Roger W. Smith is widely acknowledged, the aesthetic design, particularly the hands and numerals, can be a subjective 'blocking point' for some collectors who prefer other classic styles like Breguet or Daniels.
• When considering a high-end watch, key priorities often include dial beauty, size for wearability, quality of finish (case, dial, movement), potential resale value, and rarity.
• The wearability of Roger W. Smith watches, particularly their thickness, should be carefully considered as they may not easily fit under a shirt sleeve, contrasting with the current trend for thinner watches.
• Concerns about the long-term continuity and servicing of independent brands are valid, but Roger W. Smith has a 'deep bench' of qualified independent watchmakers and established firms like Charles Frodsham capable of servicing his timepieces.
• Roger W. Smith prioritizes technical performance over aesthetics, as evidenced by his consideration of an overcoil hairspring for Series 2 watches only if it proves to offer superior results, not merely for its traditional appearance.
• The work of Derek Pratt, a significant but lesser-known figure, is held in high regard by those in the know, with his unfinished projects being completed by esteemed watchmakers like Kari Voutilainen and Josh Shapiro, illustrating the deep respect for true horological mastery beyond mainstream recognition.