Patek Philippe 5905pt vs. 5170p Trade Dilemma
Collection

Patek Philippe 5905pt vs. 5170p Trade Dilemma

By patekvcap · Aug 5, 2019 · 20 replies
patekvcap
WPS member · Patek Philippe forum
20 replies2428 views1 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

opportunity knocks at my door today. A buddy is willing to trade his pp5170p for my pp5905pt blue and blue skydweller.... I m tempted ...what do u guys think? Pp5905pt is so clean and nice . Pp5170p is stunning...

20 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →
opportunity knocks at my door today. 
A buddy is willing to trade his pp5170p for my pp5905pt blue and blue skydweller....

I m tempted ...what do u guys think?
Pp5905pt is so clean and nice . Pp5170p is stunning...

 




Advertisement
The Discussion
FA
FabR
Aug 5, 2019
We are speaking of three watches among which, alas, the Skydweller is probably the most popular today...

Plus, the SD seems to be worth quite a bit more than the Delta between 5170P and 5905P, assuming similar conditions... All in all, personally I’d either decline or take the SD out of the deal😉

MR
Mr.Gatsby
Aug 5, 2019
I’d bite the bullet and do it

Unless you feel the current two watches you have served more purpose. You can always buy the SD back later if you want a more casual watch

PA
patekvcap
Aug 5, 2019
Thx for the advice

I love my pp5905pt , and the blue sky dweller. But i tried the pp5170p today, my heart was telling to go for it... Pp5170p sure looks sweet. Its such a tough call to make.. but then again,,, pp5170p has been discontinued... i assume it will be harder to acquire one anytime soon. Oh dear another sleepless night...

TL
Tlph
Aug 5, 2019
I personally prefer the dial layout of 5905.. 5170 dial just doesn’t appeal to me with the two small circles lol [nt]

FR
FRAMII
Aug 5, 2019
I agree with Fab.

But i prefer the 5905P over the 5170P. You will have to find out what’s best for you

AM
amanico
Aug 5, 2019
Keep your watches! [nt]

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Patek Philippe forum with 20 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →