Jaeger-LeCoultre Tribute To... Series Future
Vintage

Jaeger-LeCoultre Tribute To... Series Future

By amanico · May 17, 2015 · 48 replies
amanico
WPS member · Jaeger-LeCoultre forum
48 replies13202 views0 photos
f 𝕏 in 💬 🔗

Amanico explores the Jaeger-LeCoultre 'Tribute To...' series, reflecting on its role in honoring the brand's rich heritage while questioning its future direction. His post takes readers through JLC's historical gallery, showcasing iconic pieces like the 1928 Grande Complication and the Mark 11, before delving into the modern re-editions. Amanico's analysis sparks a community discussion on whether these 'Tributes' are a genuine homage or an over-exploitation of vintage trends.

48 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →

  If you have the opportunity to visit the Heritage Gallery, and to dive into the rich Patrimony of our beloved brand, don't miss it.

 You will admire old movements, pocket watches, clocks and wristwatches from all eras.

 Some are Legends, such as The 1928 Grande Complication pocket watch, the Reverso, the Ultra Thin pocket watch, the Cal 170, the Reverso and the Polaris, to mention only a few of them.

 1928 Grande Complication pocket watch:

   

 


Others are beautiful, like the Triple Dates, Moonphase, Memovoxes, or / and original, like the Futurematic.

 Without forgetting the Historical ( Pilot watches, Torpedo Boat, Geophysic... )

 The iconic Mark 11:


   

 


The Torpedo Boat, made, circa 1895, by Edmond Jaeger, housing the Lecoultre Cal 21 RV:


  


 


 


We could indeed mention hundreds of deserving examples...


 Since 2006, JLC agreed to revisit their Patrimony.


 2008 saw the birth of one of the most known of them, the Polaris.


  


In 2010, the Atmos 1930 was re issued in the very faithful, respectful way:


 


  In 2011, two " sisters " saw the light,  along with the Tribute To Reverso 1931 and the Tributes to Deep Sea Alarm.



  

 


The white and red newcomers:

   


Now the question is to try to guess if there is a Future for the Tribute Family, or if it only a parenthesis in the JLC Catalog.


 Tribute / Homage / Re Edition...

 
These are  very close concepts.


 In fact, I don't make a distinction between a Tribute and and Homage, while I can easily differenciate them from a Re Edition.


 A Re edition MUST be strictly faithful to the original, in its volumes, technicity, aesthetics.


 The Tribute To Polaris, for example, is very very close to the Re edition:


 Aesthetically, yes, it can be seen as a re edition, as well as its volumes, but mechanically, it is not, as it houses the latest Cal 956, not the oiginal Cal 825.


 The Homage / Tribute has to keep the spirit of the original, but it can take some distances from it.


 So are these JLC Tributes.


The Tribute To Geophysic raised a passionate debate, due to the fact that JLC opted for an automatic movement, while the original had a manual winding one. ( 2014 ).





 To answer to the original question- Do we have to see a Future to the Tribute Family or is it only a parenthesis- I believe we have to think about what watches would make a good Homage.


 The size is not always an issue, as you can " adapt " the considered iconic piece to current standards as long as you don't ruin its spirit.


 A negative example: Can you imagine a Tribute To Mark 11 which would be 44 mm big and 15 mm thick?


 A positive example: The Tribute To 1931, which is to me the perfect example of a superbly solved equation.


 The real, main, most important point seems to be the spirit of the " Tributed " piece, then.


 So, now the crucial question:  What are these watches which could  and which would deserve to be " Tributed "?


 Of course, we all have in mind an immediate contender, but besides this one I don't have to name again, what else?


 Here are several options...


 1/ A last watch, to definitely close the Vintage Diving  thema: the Master Mariner Deep Dea.


 It would be an exciting adventure, in my opinion.


 The watch is a tad small for our current standards, but it has a real personality and in a certain way, it is a lovely witness of this era ( End Sixties ) :


  


Making it bigger without loosing its charm... That may be an interesting defy.


 2/ The Mark 11.


 The easy choice, and somewhat, it would also be a logical choice.


 While IWC, G.O and some others introduced re issues of their Pilot watches, we have no alternative from JLC.


 Astonishing silence.


 Here again, the 35 mm case will certainly have to increase, but I guess there is a compromise to find, IF JLC decides to work on an all new manual movement, as the original had a great one... Which doesn't seem to be in the tube, since the introduction of the Tribute to Geophysic and its automatic movement...


 3/ The Futurematic.


 A great contender for a new " Tribute " .


  


 A look of a great purity, the originality of the crown located on the back side, a timeless piece, which could easily adopt the MUT  39 mm case... which is just sublime.


 Tempting...


 4/ A Triple Date.


Here, I have serious doubts.


 Not that the original is lacking of interest, it is just one of the most sublime JLC watch.


 The case, the lugs, the dial, all is awesome on this watch:

 

 But, we already have a Master Moon, and if you want to rework its case ( Master Ultra Thin, for example ) a bit, you may well  have a superb watch...

 No need for a Tribute, in my point of view.

 5/ A Mystery.

 Clearly the " off the beaten paths " solution.

 The Mystery is a magic watch, and, it its simpler version, its beauty is breathaking ( The E 334, on the catalog posted below ) :


  


A 35 mm  case which could easily be 38 mm big without compromising its aesthetical virtues.


 A great way to read the Time, definitely.


 6/ AND / OR ... Some nice clocks or instruments.


 The impressive expression of Diversity, and some great and original timekeepers.


 Here, I think about the Clock which was shaped like a Sputnik or a Flying Saucer, I don't know how to call it, or the terrestrian globe, the " Rue de la Paix Lampadaire ", the Barometer, the famous rear view mirror, an amazing camera, big as a cigarettes pack...


 The expression of a kind of poetry, imagination, adventure, humour.. The expression of an era.


 Here are some interesting examples:


  


 
 
 
 



 ( Most of the pictures have to be credited to Artcurial ).


  


And I didn't mention the lovely Travel Clocks you will find on the Memovox Reference post.


 Do you imagine a set of 2 or 3 of them?


 Me yes, definitely.


 7/ The " Fiction " option:


 Here, I mean watches which didn't exist, but which are so close to the Vintage spirit that they would have been released.


 The Deep Sea Vintage Chronograph is the only example I know, to this day, if we consider Jaeger-Lecoultre watches:

  



So, now, it is up to you, please share with us your thoughts, dreams, ideas ...


Looking forward to reading you,


Best,


 Nicolas.



This message has been edited by amanico on 2015-05-17 00:07:31 This message has been edited by amanico on 2015-05-17 21:24:07 This message has been edited by amanico on 2015-05-21 14:01:56

Key Points from the Discussion

Advertisement
The Discussion
AR
Ares501 - Mr Green
May 17, 2015
Astonishing post

First of all thank you for showing us back of the 1928 Grande Complication pocket watch we usually see only face I must add that I really like your propositions for hommages and I think that some are already in pipeline ;) Best D

AM
amanico
May 17, 2015
I wish there is some place for a Tribute of one of the suggestions, indeed.

I don't see JLC releasing another wirstwatch Tribute, for the moment... Best, and thanks for looking, Damjan. Nicolas

DA
Dave G
May 17, 2015
Beautiful photos Nicolas...

Shows the diversity of pieces produced by the Manufacture, all very spectacular in their own way.

AM
amanico
May 17, 2015
Thanks for looking and reading, Dave. [nt]

HS
hs111
May 17, 2015
Very stimulating post !.. Makes one think.. These only for aficionados, as the series mostly are rather small ?.. On the other hand..

.. pieces such as the Reverso Tributes, incl the colored ones, are parts of a series, a family, strong enough, to be for themselves.. Well, the edition of a black TD, as mentioned by you, might also be accepted well. Finally any sort of WT, maybe including an alarm (?), could be attractive.. Remains the logical question - do we in fact need the Re-Editions or Tributes/ Hommages ? - Or are they just a quest to relive the feelings, trying bonding tradition with modern watchmaking.. IMO, there is s

AM
amanico
May 17, 2015
That is a good question, indeed. A tough one, even.

Not sure there is a black or white answer. When I think about the Deep Sea Alarm, I would think that without its re edition, it would never have been as famous as it is nowadays. It always lived in the shadow of the Polaris. Now, it has its own glory. Paying homage to the past is good, only if it is not the only way to express modern horology, maybe? Best, my friend. Nicolas

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Jaeger-LeCoultre forum with 48 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →