IWC Hodinkee Edition Ceratanium Review

christianch · 2019-02-11T15:37:24Z

Explore the IWC Hodinkee Edition in Ceratanium. Review its minimalist dial, flat-tipped hands, and unique material. See why collectors love this controversial pilot's watch.

Key Points from the Discussion

The Ceratanium material is a significant draw, combined with minimalist design elements and true Mark 11 historical details, making it one of IWC's best pilot watches.
The flat-tipped hands, lack of 'automatic' text, and absence of a date window are highly appreciated design choices, enhancing the watch's appeal for daily wear.
The price of the Hodinkee Edition is justified by the innovative Ceratanium material, rather than the movement, as incorporating a new caliber might have been unfeasible.
The co-branding is discreet and not a major factor for collectors, with Hodinkee's limited editions often offering unique features desired by a niche market.
In certain low-light conditions, the Arabic numerals on the dial can appear to change color, resembling the orange/faux patina of the hands and markers.
Some collectors find the design and material attractive, while others might prefer an original Mark XI for a similar price, questioning if Ceratanium is a superior alternative to steel.

The Discussion

descartes1

Feb 11, 2019

Congrats on this nice IWC, but I have a serious question

What is the appeal of buying a co-branded Hodinkee piece? Not trying to be glib, just want to understand the rationale because people do seem willing to pay a premium for co-branding with a watch blog/advertising website.

gadalex

Feb 11, 2019

Not always the co-branding.

I suspect on this occasion it might be the design and use of material that is attractive to a collector. Of course, some of us, myself included, would rather an original Mark XI for around the same money. Perhaps if IWC were to issue a pilots' watch today a material like Ceratanium would be considered a better alternative to steel.

brandon1

Feb 11, 2019

I agree w Budge that the appeal of this piece specifically stands independent of co-branding.

The flat-tipped hands, no "automatic" on the dial, no date, are very nice, and the case material is actually the kind of thing that I can see would make a difference in day-to-day wear. I didn't buy one, but I certainly see the appeal. Seeing the success of this model, it will be hard for IWC to resist repeating this formula in some slightly different form, something sure to irritate those counting on it being a LE. Congrats and happy birthday to Christian!

christianch

Feb 12, 2019

thank you ! actually I got it a month before but you wishes are very welcome :)

I really thought the material was the big special offering here. Also they removed the automatic from the dial (and the rest of the writing) that is really a bit too much

Brandon Skinner

Feb 11, 2019

Agree fully with the Baruch and Brandon1

I would ask the same question as you in regards to have the Tiffany label on the dial. I would much prefer an identical watch without the Tiffany branding.

christianch

Feb 12, 2019

I think that is different because..

is the same identical watch with an extra line of the dial. That I don't understand. I also prefer my nautilus without any co branding..but in this case it is a different model and the dial is really pristine

Key Points from the Discussion

Continue the conversation