Cartier Collection Expert Opinions

Sukan · 2023-11-13T13:11:35Z

Choosing the perfect Cartier Tank Louis Cartier for a 6.5-inch wrist. Collectors discuss size, movements (8971 vs. 1917), and service experiences.

Sukan, a discerning collector, seeks expert opinions to complete his watch collection with a Cartier Tank Louis Cartier (TLC). Having already owned a JLC and a new Tank Américaine, Sukan's 6.5-inch wrist presents a common dilemma for collectors: choosing the ideal size for a classic dress watch. His query sparks a valuable community discussion on fit, movement variations, and Cartier's service experiences.

Hi guys,

I’m looking forward to complete my humble watch collection with the last TLC. I have already owned JLC (43*25mm) and new Tank Américaine (44*24mm). My wrist is 6.5”. Small TLC is the closest to the original size. Can’t decide which one to get………

Key Points from the Discussion

The Cartier Tank Louis Cartier (TLC) reference WGTA0011 has experienced winding malfunctions and issues with running fast, leading to multiple service visits and inconsistent diagnostic feedback from Cartier's service centers.
There is confusion regarding the movement used in the large size TLC; some sources indicate the 8971 caliber, while Cartier's website lists the in-house 1917 movement. Clarification is sought on how to verify the movement and manufacturing date.
While photos might make the larger Tank Louis Cartier appear oversized, in-person wear often reveals a more appropriate fit, suggesting personal preference and wrist presence should guide the final decision.
The choice between small and large Tank Louis Cartier models can also be influenced by strap length, as smaller sizes are sometimes perceived as women's watches with potentially shorter straps.
Strap changes can significantly alter the appearance of any Tank Louis Cartier, offering versatility regardless of the chosen size.

The Discussion

Chronometer (aka yacomino)

Nov 13, 2023

Sorry I am not an expert but personally I prefer the larger one here

David H

Nov 13, 2023

I like the smaller size best, but difficult to tell in "up close" photos. The smaller one may be quartz (may or may not be relevant to you)

I don't think you can go wrong, and remember whichever you get will have different appearance if you change straps. Good luck! Tank Louis are great

Sukan

Nov 13, 2023

You re the only one

Who likes the small size. Come to think of it, the strap might be too short as it is considered women’s watch

cazalea

Nov 13, 2023

I like the smaller one too

enjoythemusic

Nov 13, 2023

Both, larger for you and the smaller one for your wife / mistress / girlfriend.

Cpt Scarlet

Nov 13, 2023

Hold on … that’s four watches 😉

Key Points from the Discussion

Continue the conversation

Related Articles