Breitling Superocean Heritage '57: Vintage vs. Re-Edition Comparison

amanico · 2020-05-21T00:21:08Z

Explore the Breitling Superocean Heritage '57 re-editions, including the 'Rainbow' models. Amanico compares vintage vs. new, sparking debate on design, movements, and Breitling's strategy.

amanico

WPS member · Horological Meandering forum

30 replies5186 views12 photos

Nicolas (amanico) offers a detailed comparison of the vintage Breitling Superocean Heritage '57 alongside its contemporary re-editions, including the controversial 'Rainbow' limited editions. His insightful post prompts a community discussion on Breitling's design choices, movement philosophy, and the evolving market for vintage-inspired timepieces. This article delves into the nuances of these releases, exploring collector sentiment and technical considerations.

30 collectors discussing this on the WatchProSite forumJoin the Conversation →

The original:

Credit picture: Fred Mandelbaum:

Mine:

Here we have a 38, 5 mm case, an ETA movement. a concave bezel, and a domed plexy.

And now, the re editions:

THE LE in black, 250 pieces:

Curiously, Breitling decided to launch a new limited edition of the " Rainbow " Superocean Heritage 57 in blue... 1000 pieces. The collector who decided to go for the black version will certainly... " Appreciate ".

And the non limited editions:

A last family picture:

Here we have a 42 mm case, 9, 99 mm high. The proportions are good even if I would have preferred a less big case. We still have the concave bezel, but the plexy has been changed for a sapphire glass.

Beating inside is an ETA / Sellita automatic movement, with a power reserve of 42 hours.

The non limited editions are serious watches, for sure. But the big question, for me, is to know what to think about the " Rainbow " limited editions. As an owner of the vintage, I have been surprised, to say the least, by the Rainbow. But on second thought, why not, after all? Why not a bot of madness? Still not very sure about my feelings on that one, and I have to see it in the real life to have a definitive feeling and judgement.

Uber cool ala rolex Daytona platinum, or a sacrilege?

Best,

Nicolas

Key Points from the Discussion

The decision to release a second 'Rainbow' limited edition in blue, shortly after the black version, was perceived as disrespectful to early collectors of the initial 250-piece black 'Rainbow' LE.
ETA movements like the 2892 and 7750 are reliable workhorses, and some collectors prefer them for their proven predictability over new in-house movements that can introduce 'teething issues,' such as the IWC Spitfire's 32110 mechanism's second hand hopping.
For watches in the 5-8k price range, the distinction between a modified ETA/Sellita movement and an in-house caliber has become less critical for some collectors, as much of the cost is attributed to brand recognition rather than solely movement quality.
While the 'Rainbow' models are surprising and fun, some collectors express fatigue with the general trend of vintage re-issues across all brands.
The concave bezel design is considered awkward by some, who feel a bezel platform should be the opposite, though this opinion is often held without having seen the watch in person.
The use of a mesh bracelet on a watch intended for diving raises concerns about its suitability for frequent exposure to salt water and sand, suggesting it might be more of a 'desk diver' than a true tool watch.

The Discussion

Bruno.M1

May 21, 2020

those Rainbow editions. Ans I confess I was amazed and even pissed when they introduced the blue rainbow. This is very disrespectful to those that were lucky to get the black. That aside it was a big mistake from Breitling to make only 250 black rainbow and I guess they realized that after about 1 minute lol. For such a big brand even 1000 is a small number so I would guess the 1000 blue are probably sold out too. The charity thing is good, very good but they could have taken another watch than

amanico

May 21, 2020

And is less expensive than this Breitling ETA powered... And I don't even mention the Longines Legend Diver, which was a bit above 1000 Euros when launched, with the same ETA movement... Now, as said, I really have to see these Rainbow, in the metal. Thanks for your feedback, Bruno. Best, Nicolas

Bruno.M1

May 21, 2020

The Tudor BB eta and the Tudor in-house BB had as good as the same price. I believe it was barely 250 euro difference About the quality... ETA and Selita ( cause Breitling uses both for that Calibre) deliver superb quality I honestly don’t care anymore if a 5 or 8 k watch has a modified ETA or in-house movement The longines legend diver is indeed a great watch but so are some Tissot and these cost only a fraction of the longines. When paying several thousands for a watch.... most of tour money g

Johnny.

May 21, 2020

however the rainbow colours looks very different and daring. The concave bezel I do find a bit awkward, looks a bit strange, in my mind a bezel platform should be the opposite. But than again I have never seen one in real life . Amazing collection you have.

jlux

May 21, 2020

Some pictures gave me the impression of a very large bezel vs the dial other pictures the proportion seems better... The "Rainbow" models are surprising but also fun. My very initial thought however was: Oh no,not another vintage re-issue (applies to all brands,not only Breitling).I for myself have now seen enough of those.

LiftAngle51

May 21, 2020

You have a point. I was just on the road to dismiss that Breitlings, and praise the good ol Navitimers. Breitling the aviation brand. Why diving? Aaaa Breitling need the cash.

Continue the conversation

This thread is active on the Horological Meandering forum with 30 replies. Share your knowledge with fellow collectors.

Join the Discussion →

Breitling Superocean Heritage '57: Vintage vs. Re-Edition Comparison

Key Points from the Discussion

Continue the conversation

More from this Forum