Why I think the Blancpain Fifty Fathoms Bathyscaphe is the better choice

Oct 23, 2020,19:32 PM
 

The larger case size of 43.6 might throw some people off but the watch is well proportioned and wears comfortably on the wrist. The larger case size also allows for a larger dial which makes this watch highly legible in both bright and low light conditions. The spartan design of the dial, large lume surface area and high polished indices and hands also help for easy time reading even in extreme low light conditions. In contrast, my main complaint about the submariner is it’s text filled small dial which looks disproportioned to the super case. I found out through Crown and Caliber’s guide to the Submariner that this watch only has a dial size of 30mm despite its large wrist presence! 

And on another note on legibility, I was also quite hesitant after Hodinkee pointed out that the hour and minute hands are similarly sized and makes time telling a tad more difficult when they are close together. But after getting some wrist time, the slight differences in size is more than enough to differentiate the 2 hands. I still cannot comment on reading the time while under water. 

As for the uni-directional bezel, the Bathyscaphe and Submariner both have good resistance which prevents it from being moved accidentally. The Bathyscaphe however feels more rough but in a good way as you would expect from a well made tool watch. The Submariner is smoother and makes me think that the mechanism is made with smaller parts. Quality on both watches are superb but I would give Blancpain a few more points simply for the high polish markers and the movement. 

The Bathyscaphe also come with a display case back, 120 hours of power reserve and is water resistant to 50 fathoms or 300 meters. The movement also allows for quick set date but the Rolex Submariner’s date change is far more superior and fast. The date change at midnight for the Bathyscaphe is not instantaneous. 

And lastly, the nato strap is well built and feels as luxurious as the watch but is tedious to wear. I would still prefer to upgrade to the simplicity of a double folding buckle when I get a chance to travel again since we currently do not have any Blancpain ADs in the country. 






Watch how the light reflects from the polished surfaces and contrasts against the matte black dial.








More posts: Fifty Fathoms

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Without reading your post...

 
 By: Mostel : October 23rd, 2020-19:34
I can tell you why everything you wrote 'does not matter' (and BTW I do not agree with what I am about to state...) ROLEX. That is all.

Thanks for a thoughtful comparison between these two beautiful pieces...always great to read an interesting and well-written owner's review ;-)

 
 By: FabR : October 23rd, 2020-20:05
The Nato strap also looks good in my opinion -- all emphasis is now visually on the case of this great-looking BP! ;-) Thanks again for sharing, and enjoy both!

Yes, nato is definitely good.

 
 By: GreggyG : October 24th, 2020-08:15
I enjoy the look and feel of the fabric but dislike how difficult is it to put it on and off and having to pass the end of the strap through 2 loops one by one. The strap is too soft and pliable to push through 2 at the same time. I would also prefer if t... 

Don’t recognize

 
 By: Jurry : October 25th, 2020-06:24
the issues you mentioned with the normal strap. I’ve been using it without any problems fir over 5 years now and it wears very comfortable

Great post

 
 By: MiguelFlash : October 23rd, 2020-21:10
I would not change the Nato strap. The Sedna gold hardware makes it unique. I have thought of getting this watch and seeing it on your wrist makes me want it even more! For me, there is no comparison, that BP over the Rolex every day. 👍

Strap options

 
 By: GreggyG : October 23rd, 2020-21:40
The nato is indeed beautiful, thick and well thought of. It also down plays the watch and adds a fun vibe to it. Not to mention it’s wearability and resistance to scratches unlike the polished center links of the Submariner. The folding buckle can be an o... 

It is quite easy to differentiate the hour and minute hands on the Blancpain. The minute hand is much narrower. It is a very well made watch, my only issue is the date. Without, and...

 
 By: amanico : October 24th, 2020-00:15
... Certainly not at 4.30 o clock, it would have been much better. Other than that, a great one, for sure. Thanks for this review! Best, Nicolas

I would prefer the date window at 3:00 where it is more symmetrical.

 
 By: GreggyG : October 24th, 2020-08:08
When my brother saw the watch he didn’t notice there was a date window until he took a 2nd glance. I guess they did a good job with color matching the date disc with the dial.

Choices

 
 By: Weems@8 : October 24th, 2020-03:02
Chose between the two. Regarding to my buying rules, Blancpain would be my choice. Rolex at the other hand, and the blue smurf is hard for me to skip, it is a submariner i like very. The same with the Hulk 116610LV, a Explorer 2 and Milgauss GV. A date ju... 

What are your rules?

 
 By: GreggyG : October 24th, 2020-08:11
Funny you mentioned buying rules. I guess we all have our own to put reason into purchasing a new time piece or to otherwise turn down a deal. I try to collect watches in pairs like these 2 dive watches.

A look into my kitchen

 
 By: Weems@8 : October 24th, 2020-14:46
Great you quest it Greggy. Rules like i only collect Patek Philipe watches; I do only wear vintage chronographs. When i collect all submariners, i go for golden day dates. When i’ve got 10 independents, i want to have a special and rare hand wound A Lange... 

Not exactly apples to apples because of the blue dial...

 
 By: myles721 : October 24th, 2020-03:38
But even if the Rolex dial were black the Blancpain is (in gold) a more versatile out of the water watch and can be worn in more formal situations but still perform as a diver.

I have the blancpain in the gold and love it

 
 By: shafran : October 24th, 2020-12:16
But I have the rubber backed fabric strap and really enjoy it. It would be a tough call against the yg blue dial submariner though