Dear Henrik,

Jan 19, 2019,13:47 PM
 

Thank you so much for your detailed answer! I agree that the watches are not really comparable. I was actually looking for the full calendar and on that occasion they also showed me the other watches. So let me share my thoughts:

Like you I found the Villeret with retrograde small seconds the least interesting of the bunch. The blue dial is very nice, but overall I much prefer the moonphase over the retrograde small seconds. The dial of the Ultraplate does not have enough spice, IMO.

The full calendar in white gold is very appealing. But to be honest, I found the blue a bit too dark (almost purplish) and for a dress watch I prefer the white dial which is very classy and more under the radar. I find this the best looking full calendar I have seen (along with the VC Historique). Some time ago I had almost bought the 38mm version, but found it slightly too small on my wrist. 40mm is just perfect!

Now, the surprise favourite was the Bathy in gray ceramic! The blue dial is stunning. The Bathy is much easier to wear than the 5015, especially because it is 2 mm thinner. As much as I love the design of the 5015, I found it too thick and bulky on my 17 cm wrist. My only complaint about the Bathy is the date (but at least it's quite well integrated).

Finally the Milspec. This is surely a spectacular watch and I have to say that the size looks quite perfect on the picture (it feels a bit small when you put it on after the Bathy...). It just doesn't work very well as dress watch (which it is not supposed to be!). I need to try it again in casual clothing.

So the full calendar in steel, the Bathy in gray ceramic and the Milspec are on my list. Not sure yet which I will get (first).

Best,
Matthias



More posts: Fifty FathomsMilspec

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Quintessential Blancpain: two classic moonphase calendar timepieces

 
 By: shortys home : September 1st, 2018-04:09
We often discuss the sports watches made by Blancpain, the Fifty Fathoms and Bathyscaphe models are in the focus of many here in the forum, besides obviously the vintage marvels. Now let's take a closer look at the very core of Blancpain, two timepieces w...  

Thanks for sharing Henrik

 
 By: traineract : September 1st, 2018-04:33
I've always admired the villeret and their dial layout for the calendar. V nice and proportional. The movement looks v well finished too. I think the 35mm would work pretty good on my wrist actually haha

Very nice photos of this Villeret pair....do I smell something brewing here? 🧐

 
 By: Clueless_Collector : September 1st, 2018-07:29
I was right identifying the future Moderators like Mark, KMII and CC 😬

Wow Henrik, lovely photo shoot of a lovely pair πŸ‘

 
 By: Maltie : September 2nd, 2018-00:43
Congratulations. I have the feeling you might become the owner.

Thank you so much!

 
 By: TJMike : December 3rd, 2018-23:31
Your photographs are absolutely stunning. I was amazed by the ref 6654 when I saw it for the first time on Blancpain's website. Your review of the watch has made the watch my "grail". It will be my next purchase.

Blue dial

 
 By: Jurry : December 31st, 2018-04:13
I always admired blancpain for their nice creamy white dials but this blue is stunning

Visit at the Boutique

 
 By: almapama : January 17th, 2019-09:04
Dear Henrik and all, Inspired by your post and the fantastic pictures I visited the boutique myself today to try the full calendar and some other pieces. I would like to share some pictures and would be very interested in your thoughts. The Ultraplate has...  

Dear Matthias, what a selection!

 
 By: shortys home : January 18th, 2019-09:29
Since it’s quite diverse it’s not easy to compare, e.g. a white gold Villeret Quantieme Complet with a Tribute to Fifty Fathoms MilSpec πŸ˜‰ Between the beauties shown I personally find the last three most compelling. The Tribute to Fifty Fathoms MilSpec is ... 

Dear Henrik,

 
 By: almapama : January 19th, 2019-13:47
Thank you so much for your detailed answer! I agree that the watches are not really comparable. I was actually looking for the full calendar and on that occasion they also showed me the other watches. So let me share my thoughts: Like you I found the Vill... 

Beauties

 
 By: Jurry : February 9th, 2019-02:51
Two beauties and superb watches The history of the Villerette line is visible and classical The ladies model might benefit from few more diamonds to distinguish it more from the white ladies sports watch like the bathyscape