Oh dear

Jan 12, 2019,07:27 AM
 

.....this is so so much worse in many respects than VC’s '56 moment' or PP's new 24.

Aesthetic opinions vary, and I have not seen these in the flesh……but one has to only look at a dial here and swallow back the bile. What are AP thinking?  These have nothing going for them (polite cough - cheap and nasty  - cough).  

For me it’s all about the movements: I.e. what can I expect in a RO case soon…. Finally some kind of chrono!

but wait, what about reliabliity/timing etc?  Unfortunately no information.  Who knows.    They seem to have taken some learnings from benchmarking Rolex 4130.  I can see maybe some evidence of the Rolex reset approach…good but ....  No info…  

For most of us this is a more important announcement than any in the recent history fo AP and they buried it in the launch of a new range of utter detritus.

The case is an intriguing technical masterpiece, but not my taste.

My main worry is the lack of value in the movement finishing.  It  is just too perfunctory.  This is JLC level -  which is fine, but at JLC prices then please.

Velociphile


More posts: Royal Oak

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

So the new AP Code11.59 line is out

 
 By: Mohannad (aka Riddler) : January 12th, 2019-03:14
Introducing: CODE 11.59 By Audemars Piguet (VIDEO) https:// www.hodinkee.com g And we have a new integrated column wheel chronograph at last Maybe it will see it’s way to the RO line later
login to reply

I just saw the CODE 11.59 release . . .

 
 By: M4 : January 12th, 2019-03:36
. . . and there's much to digest: 13 models, 6 movements including 3 that are new from the ground up. As with all things AP, it's best not to rush to judgment. But I'll say this right now, the case and lug design are exceptional. BTW, all models are 41mm ... 
login to reply

Movements and case top notch, rest absolutely garbage.

 
 By: villeret18581 : January 12th, 2019-03:43
Seems like AP focused all their creativity in the case and had nothing in mind for the dials. Why are they considered as holy trinity again?
login to reply

Same thoughts [nt]

 
 By: CGJ0 : January 12th, 2019-12:50
login to reply

I am trying to understand

 
 By: iadxb : January 12th, 2019-03:48
What all the fanfare in their teaser campaign was about. Why did their suppliers told them they were crazy? Why did they have to push the limits of watchmaking? What was all the struggle and the resulting 'Eureka!' moments for? I was hoping we would see s... 
login to reply

+1. If this is pushing the limits of watchmaking then..

 
 By: pv45 : January 12th, 2019-05:27
...AP should accept, like Panerai with the Luminor and Radiomir, the Royal Oak and RO Offshore is really their only offering of interest. Their dial design with the date at 4.30 is somewhat lacking against others high end brands in the price point.
login to reply

The new chronograph movement with jumping minutes is really amazing

 
 By: descartes1 : January 12th, 2019-04:17
These watches are going to be very desired by athletes and celebs. Production is very limited initially. They will become a thing to have, and it will spread from there. I can imagine a steel version on a rubber strap that would be very appealing
login to reply

Please do not get me wrong and judge from my nickname

 
 By: Langepedia : January 12th, 2019-05:30
But how the hell the chrono movement is amazing? I mean they say they're driven by complications and the first in-house chrono that came in 2019 (!) looks like some 70s chronograph. I love watchmaking before any brand and have huuugee respect for AP; that... 
login to reply

In house instantaneously jumping minutes, column wheel chronograph

 
 By: descartes1 : January 12th, 2019-06:26
Ask yourself who else does that?
login to reply

....Lange for 20 years, Patek, Vacheron for 10? [nt]

 
 By: Cognac_XO : January 12th, 2019-07:16
login to reply

Exactly [nt]

 
 By: descartes1 : January 12th, 2019-08:01
login to reply

Is it really instant-jump? Appears not in video (see screenshots)

 
 By: brandon1 : January 12th, 2019-09:58
Screenshot from the video on Hodinkee. ...  
login to reply

From these screenshots..

 
 By: iadxb : January 12th, 2019-10:06
..it looks like the minute counter is indeed progressing linearly. Not only it doesn't jump instantaneously, but not even semi-instantaneously a la Primero, Piguet, Valjoux 7750, etc.
login to reply

Well, if true, that would be a real disappointment

 
 By: descartes1 : January 12th, 2019-11:15
The promotional materials suggest otherwise by saying it’s a jumping minute chronograph. Also, while I suspect that this line will be very popular with athletes and celebs (and that may generate sales) the market trend these days really favors steel sport... 
login to reply

Sadly it is sweep minutes, not jump

 
 By: Cognac_XO : January 12th, 2019-13:00
They had 20 years to respond to the Datograph and clearly decided it wasn't worth it.
login to reply

Do we view this as an answer to the Dato?

 
 By: brandon1 : January 12th, 2019-13:38
In construction and finishing I see it much more as an answer to the Rolex 4130, JLC 751, and as a way to replace the FP 1185 with something they can really call “in-house.” What do you think?
login to reply

Perhaps more details of the new calibers will emerge in due time..

 
 By: iadxb : January 12th, 2019-20:04
But for now the only reason the CEO mentions for creating the new chrono caliber is because people wouldn't stop bugging him for it. So yes, now they can put this new movement in their chrono models and say 100% in-house.
login to reply

Talking about instant date jump

 
 By: Zaroja1966 : January 13th, 2019-15:49
AP talks about instantaneous date jump and not counter hands
login to reply

Very disappointing

 
 By: logan2z : January 12th, 2019-04:45
The only thing of significance here for me is the introduction of the new chronograph movement, which is LONG overdue. Unfortunately I think the new watch design is unattractive and the dial gives it the look of a cheap fashion watch. I'm a big fan of AP ... 
login to reply

A failure of trying to create a new icon and escape from Royal Oak

 
 By: sleepy_templar : January 12th, 2019-04:49
The dial design is very boring. Sorry AP.
login to reply

Speechless

 
 By: rnaden : January 12th, 2019-05:00
Daniel Wellington with a nice case and movement.
login to reply

Huge disappointment ...

 
 By: Watch_kha_wen : January 12th, 2019-05:01
I even thought it was a fake news at the beginning.... It looks like a Daniel wellington++... Anyway hopefully others will be more tolerant than me on their new line. For me I’ll stick to the RO Kev
login to reply

Good job they are keeping the production numbers low for the first year

 
 By: Poky : January 12th, 2019-05:20
If they are lucky, that will be all they will sell. They should stick to what they do best; RO.
login to reply

Saddens me to say this but I think the Holy Trinity should now be officially changed to PP, VC & ALS [nt]

 
 By: chrono.logy : January 12th, 2019-05:51
No message body
login to reply

That's very silly. [nt]

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : January 12th, 2019-09:41
login to reply

What holy trinity? [nt]

 
 By: Arie - Mr Orange : January 12th, 2019-14:40
login to reply

There's a lot to take in, and I agree sometimes it takes a few days or weeks or longer for us to really see and appreciate something new like this.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : January 12th, 2019-06:14
From what I've read, and seen in picture and video, there's much to like. I think the case is interesting, and appealing. The work/thought on the crystal is a nice addition. They have, whether they are good enough or not, introduced a bunch of new calibre... 
login to reply

Jay, your comments are spot on for me.

 
 By: MichaelC : January 12th, 2019-06:52
I expect the negativity here, that is what many new members bring. We are far from the old days. We can all have our own opinions, but to call something like this "garbage", it is laughable. "Consider the source", one of my Dad's favorite expressions. Bac... 
login to reply

Well said.

 
 By: HorologyMiami : January 12th, 2019-07:01
Reactions to releases like this make me want to turn my phone off for the duration of SIHH. It’s so easy for people to be negative on social media about a release like this with their own objective taste in watches, not to mention the majority of those ba... 
login to reply

I credit AP, or any company, for pushing forward and trying something new.

 
 By: MichaelC : January 12th, 2019-07:27
They state it themselves, they want to dare and not stand still. I applaud the moxie. How easy would it be for this brand to only sell Royal Oaks and Royal Oak Offshores? This new collection excites me. Again, I see oodles of opportunity. And AP does pay ... 
login to reply

For me this collection looks like they tried to accomplish something new but couldn't resist to stay away from the mighty Royal Oak.

 
 By: Pour le Mérite : January 12th, 2019-08:31
It just confirms that they're too dependant on that particular line. Not exactly what I'd describe as "pushing forward and trying". Also the marketing was really awkward, which created lots of the negativity. The limited perpetual calender with the aventu... 
login to reply

This sub-thread of balanced and reasoned takes on the new watch line are why I enjoy watchprosite.

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : January 12th, 2019-09:46
The posts of "oh AP is finished as a brand/these watches are just like [insert cheap brand]/woe is me" are everywhere.
login to reply

You know, I like the case a lot. When I saw the teaser pictures showing the cutout lugs I was already somewhat intrigued.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : January 12th, 2019-13:16
The RO design cue, I am 100% good with. It was in my opinion an nicely thought out way to do this. The Royal Oak IS their brand right now whether they or we like it and so I think (especially when it's a positive, which the RO clearly is) the. use it, don... 
login to reply

I understand your point of view but for me it's not way to think in this case.

 
 By: Pour le Mérite : January 13th, 2019-03:27
He literally said they wanted to push forward and show that they're not just Royal Oak, yet the case band includes the Royal Oak. To say it in the words of Steve Hallock: "AP tried to look innovative without innovating, to take no risk.". Sometimes it's b... 
login to reply

I don't think the 11.59 is replacing the millenary

 
 By: benlee338 : January 13th, 2019-06:53
It's replacing the Jules Audemars Line of dress watch
login to reply

Ups, I swapped this. [nt]

 
 By: Pour le Mérite : January 13th, 2019-06:59
login to reply

The fact that they are trying to diversify away from the RO / ROO is certainly to be applauded...

 
 By: KMII : January 12th, 2019-10:13
Whether the result is all everybody expected - well looking at the responses, probably not. Yet as you say it’s early days and not all buyers are collectors - meaning tastes may differ. I feel they can be applauded for keeping the cases reasonably sized a... 
login to reply

It may be that with time, more exposure, seeing them in the metal etc that these dials have something we don't see right now.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : January 12th, 2019-13:24
Also to me, the largest and most crucial knowledge gap that many of us on these forums have is the understanding of the average buyer for these brands. Purists won't make or break these watches.
login to reply

So would you buy one? [nt]

 
 By: Arie - Mr Orange : January 12th, 2019-14:42
login to reply

Me? No. It's 41mm, too big for my wrist I would think.

 
 By: Jay (Eire) : January 12th, 2019-17:22
But that's clearly not a factor for the broader watch buying public as every brand is telling us people want larger. Ummm, except Panerai who are being told by those people that they want smaller!!!
login to reply

With the current dials as shown, no.

 
 By: MichaelC : January 13th, 2019-06:03
But if I could design my own chronograph dial? Absolutely! BTW, have you seen the Supersonnerie? I would take that as is, stunning.
login to reply

Yes I have

 
 By: Arie - Mr Orange : January 13th, 2019-06:52
Not to my taste, but a cool design exercise. When it comes to RO chronographs my preference would be an old one. With the square indexes. But those hexagon crown and pushers remain an ergonomic nightmare. Especially when one has Sasquatch hands/fingers......  
login to reply

Certainly full agreement here, as you know :-)

 
 By: MichaelC : January 13th, 2019-07:02
We had a good thread recently on the 39mm ROC collection. How interesting to see AP offer 38mm this year. But still without a spectacular dial like the older ones. ...  
login to reply

Question...

 
 By: HorologyMiami : January 12th, 2019-16:58
Michael, has there ever been this much interaction with a single post in such a short period of time?
login to reply

Well, perhaps.

 
 By: MichaelC : January 13th, 2019-06:04
I'll let you search, if you care to
login to reply

In my opinion...

 
 By: benlee338 : January 13th, 2019-02:49
I think most people only have issues with the dials, esp the chrono and time only dials, with their uncanny resemblance to "undesirable" brands such as DW or MVNT etc.. ( aka mall watches ). This can be easily fixed in future releases. The case for one ap... 
login to reply

Totally agree with your points. The dials are not specially exciting, but that can change, in the future. The case is not bad looking at all, I find the movements of the tourbillon and the

 
 By: amanico : January 13th, 2019-02:54
Chrono very nice looking... Let's wait a bit and see... Best, Nicolas
login to reply

I am with you, Ben. Lot's of over-reaction here, but this is common for modern internet forums.

 
 By: MichaelC : January 13th, 2019-06:16
Everyone has to get on record, many need to be the attention-getter and enjoy negativity. In the early days of thePuristS, most every name in this thread was not here, and the general spirit was very different. But, everyone is entitled to an opinion, and... 
login to reply

Oh dear

 
 By: Velociphile - No longer in the building : January 12th, 2019-07:27
.....this is so so much worse in many respects than VC’s '56 moment' or PP's new 24. Aesthetic opinions vary, and I have not seen these in the flesh……but one has to only look at a dial here and swallow back the bile. What are AP thinking? These have nothi... 
login to reply

At least they have new calibres, unlike those other collections.

 
 By: brandon1 : January 12th, 2019-10:10
I agree that they missed an opportunity by burying this news in the launch of this collection, but perhaps they didn't want to rehash the fact that they waited this long to introduce a chronograph. Design aside, which I think could become something cool, ... 
login to reply

Thanks for your thoughts guys. Could you help me understand the finishing issues?

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : January 12th, 2019-10:53
I see on hodinkee, the tourbillon finishing is good, right? ...  
login to reply

Sure!

 
 By: brandon1 : January 12th, 2019-11:22
Yes, to my eye the finishing on the Tourbillon is very good. While anglage is not the totality if finishing, it does give some idea of what’s going on. In this case I see nice anglage and corners. If course, this is an AP R&P movement and and is even ... 
login to reply

That's very helpful! Many thanks! [nt]

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : January 12th, 2019-11:54
login to reply

AP CEO to staff:

 
 By: remarque : January 12th, 2019-08:34
Everyone loves a simple 12-3-6-9 dial. Let's make a dress watch with lacquered dial and those arabics. But don't forget, it must be big diameter case, thick case, have no water resistance AND it must have a hole punched in the dial for a date, because I h... 
login to reply

AP CEO to Board of Directors

 
 By: xxn : January 12th, 2019-11:19
Its been fun.....
login to reply

The CEO has seen sales increase a large amount over the last years, even when the industry as a whole struggled.

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : January 12th, 2019-11:57
Their plans were that this line would be, at best, 20% of sales, which would take time to achieve. In spite of the cries of watch nerds, there is a lot potential here. So, no I don't think he'll be resigning.
login to reply

Never credit the current incumbent with the achievements of those that preceded him [nt]

 
 By: CGJ0 : January 12th, 2019-12:52
login to reply

He's been CEO for a while now and sales increased under him. [nt]

 
 By: Spangles - Dr. Tabby : January 12th, 2019-13:48
login to reply

Under him, not because of him. [nt]

 
 By: Pour le Mérite : January 13th, 2019-03:15
login to reply

;-) [nt]

 
 By: remarque : January 12th, 2019-16:08
login to reply

That dial with those torally off

 
 By: Passionata_george : January 12th, 2019-08:45
numerals ,how much dumped into the R&D ?The lugs are fine ,maybe tge new chrono will fit into a ROO case otherwise all the efforts were wasted.
login to reply

My first take says this line will be as successful for AP as the Millenary Collection [nt]

 
 By: NickO : January 12th, 2019-09:55
login to reply

Is the new Chrono movement

 
 By: GreatPilot@me.com : January 12th, 2019-12:54
being put into the Royal Oak?
login to reply

I really like the case and lugs design.

 
 By: Pretty Boy : January 12th, 2019-13:58
This line is clearly not meant to be a common classic watch line. The case diameter and thickness make it more a sporty dress watch line. Given the popularity of sports/sporty watches, this might prove to be a clever move even though a lot of people here ... 
login to reply

Well my wife who’s not a purist loves it. [nt]

 
 By: jomni1 : January 12th, 2019-16:50
login to reply

I don't see anything classic, and I say it with regret

 
 By: Mostel : January 12th, 2019-17:14
The chrono looks busy... I can imagine the case is gorgeous but... the dial? Meh. Not departing from the mundane-ordinary. The time /date looks like a 'whatever' JLC... (case probably inanely gorgeous, but crucially --dial-- whatever... shocked to see suc... 
login to reply

It looks like the JLC Polaris line from afar. [nt]

 
 By: jomni1 : January 12th, 2019-21:41
login to reply

Interesting developments...will take a lot of perusing to sink in. This luks like a completely new line. A lot of new Calibres introduced like that flying tourbillon with centre rotor. At...

 
 By: redcorals : January 13th, 2019-04:18
...last they got into enamel dials. Wonder if all this is done completely in-house. Case, dials, x2 curved crystals, crowns, calibres all are new development.
login to reply

Most of the negative comments here are on the enamel dials.

 
 By: jomni1 : January 13th, 2019-19:23
Doesn’t really look special.
login to reply

I wud agree that its nothin special but at least they dipped their toes...capability precedes capacity [nt]

 
 By: redcorals : January 14th, 2019-05:19
login to reply

If you don't like the CODE 11.59 there is a cheap alternative called the CODE41. Oh my goodness... [nt]

 
 By: LX (Alex) : January 23rd, 2019-05:18
login to reply