Audemars Piguet

Posted this in the Patek forum but let’s see what the AP cognoscenti think...   ...  

More interesting dial, the bezel bolts are a really nice touch, and I like the sharper angles. Plus, you will get way more money back for the 5711.

I'd have to go with what Michael said below. The 5711 just looks right on his wrist.

The 15400 case back looks cheap 😅 I've never understood the creation of this reference, just 2 mm more than the 15202 with a small movement. But AP can put anything inside those models, the hype on any royal oak is crazy

Depends on your perspective. If it’s financial the answer might be different. Why the question in the first place? Does one have to go? Or is it purely academic?

But that size not for you mate defo not where nautilus sits. Sell both and get a jumbo !! Plus 15500 better movement fit imho

I'd go with the AP every day of the week, but I'm not a fan I'm afraid of the 15400 or 15500 series as there's too much 'real estate' on the dial for my liking with the three handers so would go with the 5711 in this case.

Both are great pieces. If you must let one go, the AP looks big on you, but the PP fits perfectly.

AP designs are avant garde while PP are a safe bet.

Let me tell you where to send it. I’m such a nice guy that I’ll take it off your hands.

I would keep the AP, but only if it was the 15202.

I prefer the Nautilus between this two. The 5711 looks like a perfect fit on your wrist.