The quintessential Dress Watch - Which One?

Nov 11, 2022,16:35 PM
 

It’s been a while. Hope all my Purist Friends are happy, healthy and getting ready for a wonderful holiday season!


I am considering one of these, and am torn. I have owned a few 1815 in the past, but never a VC. The previous 1815’s were sold while I was chasing something else. But I have settled down with that, so the timing is better to add one of these beautiful Rose Gold pieces. I’ve always been drawn to blue hands with printed numerals, but the VC dial is insanely attractive as well. Both have pleasing sub dial layout, both approx 38 mm x 8 mm, both with stunning movements to admire and both from well respected Manufacturers. But which one??

*Pics borrowed 









More posts: 1815

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

The 1815 is 1815, where the VC is timeless.

 
 By: COUNT DE MONET : November 11th, 2022-17:04
Very hard to decide! The VC is a bit "sportier", more masculine, where the Lange is pure poetry, very calm and gentle. The play with light and shadow on the VC is also superior to the Lange. Sorry, but if not both ... I can't decide! 😃

Two excellent timepieces. There's no wrong decision. The privilege of choosing is entirely yours because you are the one who will wear it.

 
 By: BigAppleBill : November 11th, 2022-17:31
My best advice is to choose the one that best fits your personality, lifestyle and overall sense of style.

I have to go VC...

 
 By: mdg : November 11th, 2022-18:00
...but it's difficult to articulate the reasons. If I could I'd get both, but the VC has a sharper look to it...a bit more modern for lack of a better word...

Cannot go wrong with either.

 
 By: KCLQMULKU : November 11th, 2022-18:23
Good luck!

I love both of these watches, but for me there's actually no contest

 
 By: blau : November 11th, 2022-18:54
1815. The VC is a wonderfully subtle watch, but that rose gold 1815 is just breathtaking. 1815 dial and hands just leap out at you in a way that the VC, I think, doesn't. I look at the VC straight on and think, "Yes, everything is just as it should be." I... 

This VC always

 
 By: TeutonicCarFan : November 12th, 2022-00:15
One of my all time favorites

Love Lange but in this case.....

 
 By: TonyR : November 12th, 2022-00:20
I'd go with that VC.

The 1815 shown in the pic

 
 By: yming : November 12th, 2022-03:42
Is the 1st gen - 36mm.. the current 38.5mm has a different look.. thinner bezel + railway min track closer to bezel.. seems like minor changes but does change the look of the watch

Very keen observation

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : November 12th, 2022-13:08
To my eye, the biggest differences of 36 vs 38.5 mm are 1) the blued steel hands instead of the rose gold hands and 2) the stepped semicircle on the dial instead of none. After closer reexamination of that pic, it appears you are correct. Perhaps the owne... 

It could be YG

 
 By: yming : November 12th, 2022-17:02
The 36mm 1815 YG came with blue hands.

Personalily I'll chose 1815, the movement looks better.

 
 By: RayLoveWatch : November 12th, 2022-08:27
Actually I never know why vc does not use free sprung balance.

 
 By: mahesh : November 12th, 2022-09:37
for something monochromatic... Dress watch but with a character....then VC American ! something a tad warm still clean... Best, mahesh., ...  

Excellent suggestions!

 
 By: amanico : November 12th, 2022-09:38

Thanks all for weighing in!

 
 By: Aquaracer1 : November 12th, 2022-13:08
👍🏻

Truth be told

 
 By: Blourenco : November 12th, 2022-20:08
Don’t don’t think that photos are important but the way these two watches once worn make YOU feel is what matters. Whist the VC exudes class and taste, the 1815 would make me feel better in the long run. Honey gold preferred however.

Both are great pieces...

 
 By: patrick_y : November 13th, 2022-00:28